In the same way in Mad Max films, having used himself as a human decoy, the Mel Gibson character is shown, exhausted waiting as those who have been chasing close in. He looks out, seeing the plane, or convey getting away, and the whole stance says what has been said in so many books and movies: “they aren’t coming back....are they?”
Regarding Booth Gardner. In the reverberations which will continue for some time to come in my life I stand on the edge looking out and know that ‘they’, modern medicine, the advances in science, the doctors and specialist, they aren’t coming back for me.

I never really believed, not REALLY that there wasn’t some cure or specialist out there who could change my condition, they just had to want to. Yet it is always different when you hear from the white coats.
I am sorry.
In going to Booth Gardner I carried your compassion, your best wishes, your donations, your kindness and the best hope of both of us.
But before going to Booth Gardner, we made one last attempt to get Vancouver's head neurologist letter which Booth Gardner did NOT have and which neither my previous Victoria neurologist nor my ex GP (Jimmy) could find. It had the nerve conduction tests and other data so we asked the ex-GP's admin worker and suddenly it WAS found, in his file no less (he was away on vacation). We got it the day we left Victoria to go to Booth Gardner.The letter had in it not only extensive diagnostic information, but an order to begin the IVIG treatment which I had been trying to get for two years, as anecdotally it was one of the few things to stop autonomic failure progression. After the nerve condition the IVIG had been approved.
The letter was a year old.
Last year: last May, the Victoria Neurologist and the GP were instructed to created an autonomic failure baseline and then administer three to six months of IVIG. As this treatment was the best chance for both autoimmune an non-autoimmune diseases of autonomic failure. If autoimmune was discovered, or the baseline showed a slowing, stopping or improvement, then I could continue to another medication or stay with IVIG, depending on results.
This letter was never shown to me. Instead the Victoria Neurologist and my now ex-GP (Jimmy), in daily contact, told me that taking a baseline would NOT lead to treatment (the neurologist said this to my face, it a session we recorded without her knowledge). She had previously told me that the province would NEVER authorize IVIG as my problems were ‘in my head’ and worked to have me put into a locked ward instead. After I made a formal complaint she was removed from the case and the opening for the locked ward disappeared.
My GP, Jimmy, however for the next 11 months, not only had the letter but twice pulled it up on his computer to read sections to me (but never had a copy for us). He also during this period refused to refer or authorize all diagnostic care, all specialist referrals, including the many, many requests for a neurologist. Nor the requests for endrocrinologist and refused to treat the anemia or thyroid, or even test the hormone levels (as the medication required every 6 months for liver function tests).
I now have a GP I have met once, and I need a neurologist referral, a baseline test, and then IVIG treatment. In the Canadian system that amount of referrals will take between 11 and 14 months. Would I already have received IVIG treatment having a neurologist a year ago? Yes, I would have had at least six months of treatment by now.
Even if somehow the treatment could begin tomorrow, I will NEVER regain the nerves that are lost, never be able to leave the house without an oxygen converter as my lungs are failing, I will not have the extensive brain damage reversed, never again the same
in reserves nor will I be able to take a normal dump for the rest of my life (oddly rather important: don’t take one for two weeks and see if you agree?). There is a year of permanent nerve damage. Last year, I was one month from my Japan trip, a trip which Linda said a few months ago, simply could NEVER happen again, in my condition.
My GP, the person entrusted for my care, told me I would only receive treatment if a specialist told him what to do. A specialist told him to give me IVIG. He did not. Instead he told me he would only give me treatment if I went to the US for diagnosis. The province felt that I had a serious enough condition to spend $18,000 and perhaps more to TRY and save me. My GP ensured, by not allowing a neurologist referral that no one else would ever see this letter (as if I had a neurologist, the letter would have to be forwarded or they could contact Vancouver themselves).
That was what we read in the Van driving to Booth Gardner the day before. The pictures of me smiling at different races, races I don’t know if I am able to finish THIS year flashed on my screen saver. A year sometimes makes a great deal of difference.
At Booth Gardner, a complete history was taken as well as review of the tests and this ‘new’ letter. Booth Gardner is NOT a center for simply autonomic failure but rather a Parkinson’s center for MSA. What they could tell me is this: I did not have MSA (or a variant they were familiar with). I have central autonomic failure. I also have peripheral autonomic failure. It is not known how that is possible but it the facts. I also do NOT have POTS which is the non-lethal form of central autonomic failure. I also have peripheral neuropathy (progressive) of which there is no understandable connected cause. When asked what could cause such destruction the head Neurologist of the center said, “Heavy Metal poisoning?” (Could you PLEASE stop sending me liquid Mercury cookies!) which is like saying ‘Radiation poisoning’ as both don’t damage only the Axon, they simply warp the DNA, eat the nerves and wreck damage on a level beyond predicting. I have not, to my knowledge, been wearing my Cherynoble earrings.
The Neurologist in BC who saw thousands of people with neurological condition and a few with autonomic failure said it was not DNA related, and unknown if auto-immune related. It could be just ‘one of those diseases’ like Lou Gehrig disease/ALS was until it had a name. Why do I get it? Why me? Who knows? The head of the center which dealt with thousands of people coming with autonomic failure each year could tell me what it was: something which should be impossible – both central and peripheral autonomic failure, much less the peripheral neuropathy.
I had the lethal kind of central autonomic failure. Indeed outside of anecdotal evidence that IVIG works on some people (best with those with AAN) the ONLY hope for autonomic failure are those with MSA-P, who have a 5% chance of extending life expectancy. She felt I needed a referral to a specialist to only rare autonomic failure cases and is giving one. I pointed out that at the progression and the types of autonomic failure left, that I was not only terminal, but rapidly terminal. She agreed that ‘those with autonomic failure (of my type) had a shortened life expectancy.”
But again emphasized that I did NOT have MSA (or a variant she had seen before in her thousands of cases) and I needed to see an expert in autonomic failure (AAN, is often called MSA because no one has ever heard of it; this is what I have believed I have, however I often use MSA as it is easier to understand. She does NOT know if I have AAN). She also wrote that the anemia and thyroid needed to be dealt with. And this was my diagnosis. My Obituary.
All those words but what does it mean? It means I thought for a day and then cried a lot. It means I spent about $800+ to get the answer. The answer is no. I am terminal. I do not have a form of autonomic failure that has any way to survive or even extend life; except for the faint hope of IVIG, not currently studied in trial as not enough people can be collected or live to the end of trail period (usually 6 months to a year) to have a clinic trial. I am progressing at what appears to be 4-7 times the speed of other people with central autonomic failure. By pure stats, I should be dead. Plus I have peripherial autonomic failure, which is unheard of, but I still have both AND the neuropathy.
What can an autonomic specialist tell me? Maybe that someone else has what I have, or that it IS AAN or something new and they call it MSA-Q or they haven’t and they will want to autopsy me. Or maybe like this visit, they will end up with a list of what they know which still ends with “I just don’t know!”
Medicine isn’t coming back for me.
The question I need to answer is how much more time and energy will I spend, how much more money will I borrow, beg, put Linda into debt in order to find out a bit more about these diseases. I think Linda, Cheryl and others would like to at least a consult with an autonomic specialist. I would like what I fought for, and won, it turns out, a year ago: Treatment.
Was the IVIG withheld by the neurologist out of spite? The same neurologist who ordered another MRI because she said nothing would show up on an MRI but something did, so she ordered that section done AGAIN, and a year later it was determined to be ‘unknown.’? Why, why did my GP do it? Out of dislike? It is hard to believe that he would complain about needing guidance when he had it, that he would force us to spend money we didn’t have, money I had to beg publically for in order to get an opinion in the USA only from …confusion?
A year without treatment when I could have gotten better.
It rings around in my head like pealing of the bells.
I asked Linda the point of chasing this specialist, then the Chicago program, then the Vanderbilt? She said, maybe for another woman, another generation. I said, with tears on my face, “It’s been over 100 years and they haven’t found anything YET.”
Yesterday was somewhat dodgy, hands black from lack of oxygen, arms and legs deep purple, much like this afternoon: TIA’s, stopped breathing, the usual. I have decided that if there is a visit to an autonomic specialist I will go, but that I want to try and set up the IVIG treatment as soon as possible, within six months if that is possible, even if I have to go to the newspapers. I want to gather reserves as much as I can and enjoy life while I have it. I know that every day, and every breath is borrowed time, that there isn’t any magic cure, or hope.
And yet, I do have hope; hope that my life will be better. That I will be able to say “no” to the medicos, because they either accommodate me, or they just wait. Because either I live this life my way, or lose that chance forever.
Like the last 24 hours, there will be more depression, crying, and Linda and I holding each other. (3) But I am going on Friday to Sakura-con, if I am strong enough: I want to buy some art books for the blog. I want to buy some cat ears to send as presents.
I bought some presents today in town to send out and when the total came up went there was a, “Wha?” moment. But it is okay, because this might not be what I originally sold my books for but this is who I am.
“Why,” asked the salesperson, “would you send presents to people you don’t even know, or have never met?”
I asked her if she remembered what it was like getting a surprise present as a child. She did. I said that many of the presents were FOR children and some were to help people remember that feeling of getting a present; the child-like wonder and anticipation.
This has been the worst couple of days as I can remember. And there is a lot more staring into space ahead.
It is one thing to sort of know that you have a rather horrid death ahead and another thing to KNOW. To know that, no, they aren’t coming back to help or save you and from now on it will likely be more difficult, more painful, and yes, the road that leads to one end. 
I AM trying to notice the flowers and the sunshine, and not just that ROAD, that destination. I got a bustier and thong underwear for $17 today! I have an outfit for sakura-con, and I want, I really, really want this to just be a fun time. To be a time I DO remember, one of the good memories of this summer. Since I am Not Dead Yet, and plan to stay that way (your not sending me heavy metal or radioactive cookies would HELP in that!). As long as I breath, I want to LIVE.
Okay, I know what I have lost, I know what I am losing; now it is up to me to figure out how to make a life where I gain something, anything: from joy, from enjoyment, from just a smile.
My fucking ex-GP!!! Now there is a man who needs a postcard (and his license pulled, and a cell in the Hague for ‘Crimes Against Humanity’). Sorry, not quite all adjusted yet.



33 comments:
It makes me angry. But that won't help. So - what can we do? I am thinking of you and sending you love as always.
That motherfucking son of a bitch neuro can burn! We all knew she was an asshole, but my god, how fucked up! I can not come up with what to even say. GAH! Then the useless GP, what the hell?
I don't know the system in Canada at all so forgive me, but can they be reported? Also since you have the letter in hand can you go to the papers & complain so the public is warned?
I'm sorry Beth, I know that is weak, but I can't think of anything else to say.
Maybe medicine as a profession doesn't work, perhaps too many people are attracted to it as a career rather than a passion, I don't know.
"I want to gather reserves as much as I can and enjoy life while I have it"
It's all you can do. Keep on living. Live as well as you are able to, take what you can, take it hard and don't worry about giving it back, just be selfish and if that makes you happy then it will make those who love you happy too
I'd like for you to see a specialist because I still hope you might be able to get better quality of life. But it's your life to live, your time to make meaningful and as enjoyable as possible, so no matter what you decide, I'll support you.
Sending hugs and love.
Oh, Beth, I'm so angry on your behalf...
But what can anger do? Not much, I suppose.
I would be making plans about now, if I were in your shoes, to take all the evidence of mistreatment, lack of treatment, lies, deceptions, and refusals to treat - from all your doctors - straight to the Minister of Health for BC, and on the same day to the college of physicians, and as many newspapers as possible. When multiple doctors can conspire against a patient that way, something is totally wrong with the medical system.
I'd also, I think, be sending the evidence to the federal minister of health (but heaven alone knows why; I wouldn't expect action from Prime Minister Herpes government), AND to the Canadian Medical Association.
Revenge? Possibly, but it would also serve to help those who will share your symptoms in future.
But for this weekend, please enjoy Sakura-Con. And when I calm down a bit, I'll be sending as much strength and peaceful energy as I can.
Still with you, dear Beth, and sending love and hugs,
Neil
Wow. My first impulse (aside from wanting to scream about the horrible way they treated you!) is to hope that somebody sues that doctor for an obscene amount of money. This goes way beyond malpractice--this is non-practice, and is absolutely unacceptable. At the same time, though, lawsuits take crazy amounts of time and energy, when you could be reading manga or relaxing instead. So I don't know whether a lawsuit would be worth it, but I do know that I'm intensely upset with this GP, and I'm happy to help you fight back in any way I can--just let me know how.
I am so sorry. AND FUCK YOUR EX. GP sorry about that outburst. Those doctors should be suid or something....... that can't be legal to withóld treatment like that.
I hope that you'll get some treatment NOW even if it doesn't cure your diseases.
love
Anna
You are going to sue the shit out of this people, aren't you? I know it's not going to help your condition but it might just make them think twice about screwing with other people's quality of life if someone gives consequences to their actions.
I'm lost for words Beth. I'm so shocked and disgusted at your ex GP's negligence. I can't put it into words
Well I do have some words about you and about the now and the future ...
I hope you can now have the IVIG treatment and that you have that piece of paper with terminal written on it that will allow you to access pallative care and required pain relief (because addictive isn't such a factor for the arse covering doctor).
I know this isn't news you wanted to hear. None of your friends and family here wanted to hear it in such definitive terms. But I hope that the knowing will help, in time, to have the best battle plan and to make the absolute most and best of the life you have.
I am still here, still reading, still stumbling for the right things to say, still your friend, still writing you letters, still a part of the Not Dead Yet plan. Still your friend through it all.
I am sorry. I remember when, finally, I knew what I'd been asking for years, that the psych system could not help, even at the point of death. And that so much effort I'd spent trying to get the promised help had cost much, and gained exactly nothing. In all sorts of ways, including that it ultimately turned out to be a liberation (I *hope* there will prove to be some liberation in this, for you), that isn't comparable; but between that, as one step, and your writing, which always brings me closer to where you are, as another - I can empathise just a little. And it stinks several flavours of rotten.
I am also appalled beyond words. I wish I were more shocked, but I *am* appalled.
However, I do, fervently, hope that specialists who treat you as a sentient being *can* give you better time, if not more of it. Time *in which* there's more time for joy and sillinesss and satisfaction. And time *in which* there's more time for cat ears (do they come in tabby? marmalade? russian blue? with tails to match? - enquiring minds want to know, & wonder whether you can affix a tail to the tank) and the sort of undies which would make me itch for a week.
I don't know what to say, but my heart goes out to you.
Sadly, there's truth to the saying that power corrupts. Doctors, by the nature of their job, have a lot of power over others' life and well-being (wouldn't you know it!), and I suppose some don't choose that job for the right reasons... You know how people have to go through thorough psychological evaluation before they're allowed to become astronauts or the like? I'm inclined to think there should be the same degree of evaluation and background checking (designed to ferret out any assholish tendencies) before someone is even admitted to med school.
Ooooh, SakuraCon! I know you've been looking forward to that, and I am taking delight that it's so close. And I promise not to send you heavy metal cookies.
But, Lord hear me, I am so angry, alongside you, that your important treatment order was just filed and left, that your care has been so disrespected.
I second Neil's comments regarding evidence. To share things, so that others who come after you are protected. But that is for later; I agree, after SakuraCon!
I hope you have a marvellous time at whatever you're able to see and do there. Not Dead Yet, hrmm? :)
I'm so sorry Beth. Those doctors are evil. I'm thinking of you and sending love to you and Linda.
OMG, I'm so... beyond outrage. Seriously, if you need any help filing complaints with the College of Physicians and Surgeons, I'm here to help in any way I can.
And yeah, sue those fuckers and make sure it's all over the media.
BUT right now, please focus on Sakura-con and your lovely new undies! I hope the sun shines for you and that you take great pleasure in your con(ference)!
I can only imagine, based with some experiences myself on a much less urgent level, of the roller coaster you've been on endlessly with this sick, pathetic medical system... it's soul-sucking, energy-draining, life-depleting and it should be criminally prosecuted. Period.
I'm sending big hugs of support for you all right now. I know it's not much, but please know it is heartfelt.
Please, if I can help at all... in any way, I will do my absolute best.
I don't understand the motivations of the neurologist and the GP. That makes me really upset, that you couldn't benefit from possibly life-extending treatments. I do hope that there are some kind of charges filed against these doctors for what they've done. Why, why wouldn't they provide treatment? Even if they discriminate or don't like a patient, there is no excuse for that. They have a duty to do their job.
I'm terribly sorry that your prognosis isn't good. I am glad that you have your diagnosis at last even if the cause is unknown, a medical witnessing to what you've endured. Given that they're not sure why you have central/peripheral failure, can they register you for the NIH rare diseases program?
I hope you enjoy every minute that you can, Sakura-con especially this weekend. Love to you and Linda and Cheryl.
Booth Gardner... I heard what I expected to hear as far as autonomic failure and peripheral neuropathy but hearing it this time it seemed weightier. What I would like tosee happen next is for the new GP to treat the thyroid and anemia and see how much improvement we can get for your quality of life. I would consider an autonomic failure specialist if one can be found but ultimately it is your decision as to how much more time you want to spend visiting specialists.
As for your former neurologist and GP - every time I think of it I get a sick feeling and a wash of anger. I would love to see them sued, stripped of their licenses to practice medicine, and tried for crimes against humanity.
I'm very angry on your behalf, and I know that makes no difference.
I'm going to focus on what you can do now, wishing you joy, and sending lots of manga.
*hugs*
Lawsuit. Malpractice. There's got to be a lawyer up there that will take the case.
A YEAR AGO!
!#.(*;<*#(
Show the letter to your new doctors, maybe they can do something.
Licenses need to be pulled.
Ahem.
Was BG able to get you anything immediately useful, like pain medication or seizure medication?
Yesterday night someone told me about something anime happening in San Francisco in May, so I tried looking it up online. I didn't find the one she was talking about, but there is a couple happening in San Jose (Fanime to be the better of the two), and I saw a yaoi convention in San Francisco listed. As much as it doesn't interest me, I suppose I could see about picking up some postcards for you...
Kitty cat eared hats. Get one for Linda so she won't steal yours. Maybe get you a fox eared one for yourself?
I'm going to have to agree with Neil here.
Get photocopies of everything, one or two dozen, and mail them to every government-sponsored medical agency, newspapers, television stations, radio stations (is NPR just for the United States?), medical board, medical magazine, etc., that you can think of.
Include a list of who's getting copies.
Don't use your energy trying to see people in person. Send them registered mail, return receipt requested, must be signed by the addressee. They've got that stuff in Canada, right?
This... This just frosts me.
Beth, I can but agree with what everyone else has already said, what you have said: Your former doctors need to stand trial for criminal malpractice.
And I am glad you have some kind of answers, some direction of what to do with your limited time and energy and resources. At last, now, you do have doctors who care, so with their input, you will likely be able to make the best decisions you can under the circumstances.
But all that is for another day. For now, I hope you are focusing on Sakura-con. I am so looking forward to seeing the pictures of you cosplaying (and Linda? And Cheryl?).
Yes, I have to agree, that while I've not heard your ex-GPs side of the story, your side of it would sound to me as though you should be launching a complaint for medicinal misconduct. It might not save you, but it might save someone else...
As regards you, well I think one of the best things you have going for you in the fight against the disease is probably sheer bloody-mindedness. Sounds bizarre, but it's your unwillingness to be beaten that keeps you going.
So keep fighting, and keep being you.
Thanks all, We all had a day of swearing at the GP, and then after Booth Gardner, there was a day of silence as we sort of had the 'well we KNEW they were going to say that, just we didn't know they would say it so well, definitively!" plus no new help on the siezures or pain meds or anything else, that is all a mystery to them - in fact I am, except that, sort of like the wicked witch, I seem to be melting, "AHHHH, I'm MELTING!" - I wonder who will inherit my flying monkeyies?
Well, I guess the success then is that they didn't dismiss you and can actually see what's in front of them.
Yes, I don't doubt that they do the same to other patients, especially women. Who under their care is not having cancer treated or is having lupus or MS ignored because they think it's psychological? The psychological issues are theirs, and they need their sexism treated as it's affecting their ability to practice. It's turned out my GP is a lot like this guy too and I'm still trying to find a new one but haven't had time and if we change insurance with new jobs might have to turn around and go to someone different immediately. Am using my rheumatologist and gyn as primary care in the interim and hoping they don't catch on.
I really feel angry about this. Medicine is failing people with disabilities, women, other minority groups.
I'm with Raccoon--any publicizing can be kept simple if you need it to to conserve energy--"I have a terminal disease, IVIG was prescribed, they denied it." I mean, just a few weeks ago he was chiding Linda and Cheryl for not taking you to Seattle when one treatment was already in his hands!!
I have a lot more to say and could keep on railing but don't want to exhaust you. I wish I could comfort you more.
Elizabeth,
My heart is broken. I had such hopes for Booth Gardner. I thought that even if they could not save your life, they would be able to get you on a treatment plan for pain, seizures and maybe even endocrine and auto-immunune stuff.
But they failed you.
I thought they would come back for you. I really did. I thought someone would.
And now I grieve for your losses; the lost year, the lost hope, the lost family. This isn't right on so many levels it is just an endless loop of not-right
I am, so heartbroken right now, I don't have the energy to be angry at your GP and neuro. When OSM can't get angry, you know it is serious.
The only thing I can say to offer some spark in the abyss, is that even though they aren't coming back for you, *we* aren't going to leave you.
I know it probably isn't worth much, but there you go.
No help with the seizures and pain meds? Oh, crap. I had hoped that they would do that at the minimum. I don't really know what else to say. It really is a punch in the gut being denied the treatment it has been explained that you need (to put it very mildly indeed). I am outraged. But my words are all crap and too small.
Thinking of you, and sending hugs. I shall, of course, still be with you in spirit (and e-mail) until the end. I won't be going away.
I want dibs on the flying monkeys!
So what am I going to do with this batch of liquid mercury cookies I made for you? I broke a lot of old thermometers!
My heart hurts for how you must feel. I can't imagine....
I don't know what to say - I wish there were some magic to change things but if there is nobody told me. I can only send love and best wishes.
I think that blogging about your story may help change things - I hope so.
(Sorry I've been absent from comments for a while - I was hit by fatigue plus demands of work after a winter virus but have now recovered entirely thanks to a short break with friends.)
So are either Booth Gardner or the new GPs recommending dealing with residual heavy metal in any way, at least to minimise *further* damage?
Heavy metal is disturbing stuff.
I am assuming they were not just talking about you listening too much music in the 80s...
I am so angry for you, Beth. I hate believing that people can do such things to others. How can your doctor have done that?? Your DOCTOR of all people. Aren't they supposed to serve life, if not anyone else? My heart aches. I don't know what IVIG is but I hope it can at least slow whatever effects are still to come from your diseases... so that you can live.
Beth, I am so very, very sorry at your news, and so very VERY angry at your so-called doctors. I agree with everyone who's said this should surely be criminal negligence... but perhaps to pursue a case might be just too much for you and Linda now. I hope some crusading human rights lawyer (anyone know one?) might take it up? The whole thing seems so very unfair - legally, morally, humanly, you name it. Further words just fail me.
Love & peace
hugs hugs and more hugs.
That and (being the American I am, even though i'm transplanted in Europe) sue the miso-bag doctors. You've got a paper trail now.
Dear Beth,
yes, go to the appointment. Try to get the IVIG. There are organizations here that can help & advise - don't know what you have in Canada, but it seems to me that the USA ones would help you. I wish I could share some of my IVIG with you!
I'm not terminal, but I've had that sinking feeling, that sense that everything is drawing in around you. Here I am, 3 years in & getting treatment for Lupus & CVID & still not much better, still fighting to hold on to what bits of my life I can. And sometimes I think, what if that idiot rheumatologist had dxed my Lupus in 1992? What if my immune deficiency had been recognized sooner, if my IVIG treatment had been started 15, 10 or even 5 years ago? And I have hopes of getting better. I wish I could share some of that hope with you too. But get the IVIG! Get whatever you can. Anything that may help you feel better, stay longer.
I hope one of these doctors is helping you with pain control.
Love, Sharon
Post a Comment