Wednesday, November 05, 2008

Grief and Hope

I have noticed that people don’t know how to deal with this word: Grief. Grief. It is the intense and painful emotions experienced when someone or something a person cares about either dies or is lost.

But we don’t deal with grief; we can barely talk about the grief of losing a pet, and over people loved by us, there is an empty well of silence in this society. There is no where to speak of it, when you scream, there is no echo.

the grief of losing a pet is severe. “The emotional pain from losing a loved one, whether it is a spouse, child, parent, sibling, friend, or pet, can be the most severe suffering a person must endure.”

And for the person losing themselves, their life, and every single person or thing that is important to them: that is suffering. It is relentless and unending, never stopping from tainting everything they must cope with.

So when experiencing something like the loss of books the other day; I have traded or bought or sold books for 30 years. These are books that took me 30 years to collect: they are my memory, they are my plan for the future, my life, my stability. People who know me know that I AM books, I have read over 20,000 books. I used to read 1,000 a year. And now, even that, my last wall, is chipped away and I am the one who must do it. People don’t know what to say, don’t understand what it means: Better to lose books and live longer, right? Except I probably won’t live longer.

Should I say to people, “Hey, better to lose ONE of your kids, you know, cause you’ll live longer.” Or “Better to lose that ear.” Except, wait it isn’t over, another week, another loss, “Oh well, better to lose that eye.”, “Better to lose those fingers”, “Better to lose those toes.”, “Better to lose that arm” – how much more do you want to take. It is rather unpleasant reading isn’t it? Almost offensive. No, It isn’t offensive, it is OBSCENE. But it is happening. And if you can’t look at it, then you can’t realize that is what people have to go through, or that is what Linda and I go through daily. Then I guess you aren’t friends. And you will, like so many more, drift away. Until YOUR day comes, that time you wake up that day and it is as if you have slowly drunken a bottle of broken glass, and you feel it ripping you apart from inside. That is grief.

See, there is palatability to emotions: To our expectations, our hopes, and our futures. We put something aside a DVD to watch later, a book to read later. We start a course, we take a job, we plan on advancing, plan on going out on weekends, plan on vacations, plan……a future.

This is hope, this is looking ahead, this is having spring, or even in winter, the knowledge that spring will come around again. ‘Abandon all hope for those who enter here’ is what is said going into hell. Because those there could never go home, could never look forward to spring, or change, or growth, or anything but the horrid existence of now. Without hope, how does a person go on; the bible calls it one of the Great Three, second only to Love. It is hope that makes people sacrifice for their children, hope that makes people fight for countries, hope for a better future. But if there is not future, is there is no spring.

That I am here, that I write at all is a miracle. I was abandoned, several times in my life. And until you have been KEPT, been a THING, for the physical and psychological amusement of others. You have hope, every day, that someone will come. That THIS day, someone will come and stop what is happening as your ability to create dissociative states and enter them becomes as easy as slipping in and out of a shadow (a dissociative state, or with me, a dissociative fugue state which creates alternative personalities). I created the ‘part’ of me who could use all of my mind and become the seductress, the submission, the broken, whatever they wanted of me. There was a part (actually at least two parts) of me that were locked away, one for safety, and when it was over, they switched; the ‘good’ me came out, and the dirty me, was locked away, in a steel room, with those guys, waking every day to those memories, re-experience being abused, tortured, every day, for eternity. I did that to my self, or to a part of my self.

The only cost is having nightmares every day of your life.

I won’t go through it all, what happened as almost an adult while I lived in the woods; or the time when I was subject to a level of phsycial, psychological, verbal and other abuse for month after month which even the police found appalling, so much they brought in a special prosecution unit. No one came for me then, particularly not family. And I didn’t turn into a psychotic killer or go with someone who beat me, because I know I can handle that. I don’t live a life with rage, or endless revenge. Nor did I create a destructive dissociative personality (well, except self destructive). I could, it would be as easy as putting on a shirt; to go over, even in my wheelchair to every single relatives house and burn them to the ground, and to go to my parents condo and burn it. Which teapot that you collect mum is more valuable than me? Oh, I forgot, all of them. Burn them all, and then due to the particular nature of my disease I have about 15-30 seconds where I am literally unstoppable. What is the point of shooting someone who is full of adrenaline and doesn’t feel anything? Or beating them. Or breaking their arm. I don’t think I could stand or progress for longer than 30 seconds but I could set fire to the police department, the same one which DIDN’T come when I reported stalker or abuse to them. And I could maybe, kill a few of those who tried to escape the flames.

But that’s NOT who I am. See, that’s all still up there though, because when someone emotional tortures me by tying me up and then talks about burning you alive, or sets fire to parts of you, and I know what that kind of terror feels like. But that doesn’t MAKE me a person who does that.

So, no one is coming for me now either. I am as normal a human being as I can be, a pacifist, a person who believes in giving second and third chances, who believes that the innocent should be protected. I am a person who wants to be what was not, I want to be the person who is there, who remains, or ignores the social blanket of silence and says, “I am here for you, come with me.”

And now, I live a life where I have no hope but one, that I might live a little longer IF we get to the Booth-Gardner clinic and IF we can get the tests they want done over here in time. But no, no hope, but grief. And yet, I go on. Grief wraps itself around me, chokes me, makes me cry several time a day and yet….I go on. I would sign up for a four or six month class, but I have to live until Jan. to do that first. And that is out of my control.

This is grief. And yet, I go on. Not because I don’t feel it, but because even if on the last day of my life, I can write the message, “I’m here, I’ve come.” To someone who needs it, then I go on. The dedication of my AWARD-WINNING (heh!) novel Zed isn’t at the beginning because the book, and Zed is what is important. It is at the end. The publisher and most people thought I dedicated it to myself. Why? Because for a person to write a book over five years and care more about a single person they will never know or see, and care about them more than your own self, is an alien thought to them. No one came for me, no one will come for me. I left my dedication as a marker to those so they would know they were not alone. This is the culmination of the dedication: “to every person out there who know ‘What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger’ is not only total crap but far more likely to make you limp or ache when it is about to rain. Or to every person who realizes that the scars of facing the enemy and the scars which are self inflicted look pretty much the same. And especially to evert person out there for whom doing what you love is a giant scream saying, “I exist, I exist, I exist!” – Well, I agree. This book is dedicated to you.”

This is the trailer for Elfen Lied, about two girls, one who was taunted by the population before being subjected to experiments, abused sexually and physical for being different for 10 years before she leaves. Using her power to do so; she also has a split personality, and when she tried to bring them together….. At the end of that road, the one she decides to walk down, is the secure facility where she was kept all those years. The other girl, with pink hair, though she doesn’t realize it, is the daughter of the project director. She is sent to bring the other one back. And fails, so badly that her limbs have to be amputated but her ability (a sort of invisible hands), allows her to use prosthetics and her father faces death so that she can live a life, maybe one day a normal one, with the prosthetics he designs for her. It is graphic, sexually and with violence. Meaning, it is what occurs in hundreds of thousands of home in North America every day.


For a while, when you are not under the haze and burden of grief, when you have hope; there is joy. Whether rich or poor, abused or otherwise, irregardless of age, joy is pure. To sate your lust from another human being is not joy. Joy does not require innocence, I don’t think it requires anything but a willingness to be open to it. This is joy. It is instantly recognizable. I would like this. I thought that I could overcome grief, and loss and regain it. I knew that I would die but not soon, well I would get weak soon, and so I planned and we went to Japan and there are MANY pictures of me showing joy.

And then the money had to go to hospital beds and a walker which I used only a few months, and medical stuff, like pills and hospital rides, hundreds of dollars in hospital rides. And yet, there are pictures of joy; joy in racing, joy in Goldstream, joy in the park with the squirrels. So much joy. Even though every month the faces of joy were less and less.

And every month the losses mounted up; Damage to my temporal lobe; which appears to have healed as much as it will. Inability to convert oxygen, which leaves me unable to leave home until the concentrator comes…if it does, once we know what blue cross will cover. Loss of memory, of my life; pictures of me smiling and happy and I don’t know when that is or who I am with. Loss of the ability to read. A fatigue that grows every week, stealing time, making answering emails almost impossible. Making the daily blog the central task of the day. Seizures, now ripping muscles, bloody noses, blood in the mouth, creating more gaps of memory in a memory which has NO SEQUENCE. While other people remember this came before that, to me is like flowers floating in a bowl of water; those are the memories I have, that is what I know, and WHEN is not what I know. “What day is it?” I ask people who don’t understand what temporal lobe damage is. And they say a day and I say, “No, it is TODAY.” And every day is “TODAY” I have my own week calendar which is based on what I know and only has four days, Fridawrites day, because her name is up there, Frida, and then Saturn’s Day, then the Sun’s day and then Mundi or the Moon’s day. So my worker will say, “See you on the moons’ day.” And I will know. I cannot figure out the other days.

I am not unintelligent, though, as I said to the government branch investigator yesterday; I am not the same person who wrote that book; I am a similar Elizabeth. And each future, each bit of future brings me another loss, another ripping away of a part of me. This week it is falling down and heart problems, next week it will be something else. Something else that will cost money to fix, or time and I have little of either. But I want to live. I do get angry, I get angry sometimes at my readers, though I love them, and I love the people I send things to because why do they get to live and I don’t? They just do. And when people avoid that fact, that I will die, and avoid the fact that I AM grieving and that it is one of the most painful emotional experiences if not the greatest emotion suffering I am or have faced daily, hourly, by the minute. When they avoid talking about it, when they awkwardly join that social blanket of silence, then it is as if I or my or Linda’s suffering doesn’t exist. And that is cruel.

Dawn, who may not be able to read this right away was a person who it was hard to for me to write to. She had lived her life, knowing what I know, that there is an end, inevitable, and there. And also, that her brother had just died of the same disease a few months earlier (when I first started to try and comment on her blog). The grief must have been and still be at times almost unbearable. To have it feel that like everything in life including hope is taken away. Because that is what I feel. You see, this is the road I travel.
And this is the road most of you travel, this is the one with hope on it, the one which has blue skies and company and companionship. And while I desperately would like to be on that road, I am not. And while a few months ago I could play the ‘ahhh, this could go on for a good long time.” Now I can’t. I am on one road and you another. The reason I mention Dawn is because she started a Ph.D. and statistically she should be dead already. But she started a Ph.D. and 'statistically' she has a decent chance of never finishing. But she goes on because she loves it and because she believes she will finish and every class she teaches and paper she writes makes a difference. Doesn’t change the road she is on or where it ends but adds a few flowers, makes the sky blue. I don't know becuase I'm not Dawn. But she seems to have moments of joy.

Just to let you know. I am a competitive person and dying hasn’t changed that. Dawn has, by simply being Dawn, probably forced me more times than I can count to pull myself up once again. “If Dawn can go on, so can I”; “If Dawn has to evacuate her house and studies and fish and leave them and she can still go back and start again, so can I.”

I hate how when people are alive people are too embarressed to say how they made a difference. But when they are dead, everyone does. Why? Because dying makes your hearing better? But I guess I am just as guilty of never saying to the person what a difference they have made to me.

Thank you Dawn for being there, not to save me. But simply to show me how to keep going on; to make my competitive spirit say, “If she can do it, I CAN do it.” I know that as motivations go, this is pretty low, but still, if she can do it, I can!

Right now, I am not going through the motions, I am in motion. I do postcards, I write blogs. I spend time with Linda, I am starting some long term projects. I order things over the internet that are beautiful, because, just because I currently only have one pair of jeans small enough to fit me, and we don’t know if it is worth buying another because when I become bed-ridden, I won’t need them. That doesn’t mean I shouldn’t live this moment with the JOY of anticipation, of having something good and real and beautiful which will come for me (so WHAT if I have to pay for it! Oh that reminds me, I need to order a stiptease, hmmm how to explain THAT on the credit card?).

This IS my life. Anger, yes at both myself, my limitations of memory, of being corrected endlessly in public, in private, to have a person ask a simple question and not know. To want to give up, to destroy everything, to burn every postcard, to in an act of destruction free myself from the humiliation of trying and failing. And sometimes I do, there are wounds are my forearms that won’t heal. But it hurts, and I start again. I go on.

And is there grief? Yes, is it like having to rub crushed glass into your face, to sit and listen to professionals or OT, or PT’s or doctors or friends talk about what I am losing or going to lose? It is, it is like glass with salt rubbed after. When they say by implication how much less my losses will be because MY life isn’t equal to theirs. That their house burning down would be a tragedy, but MINE burning down, as it currently is, all around me, is something I am supposed to be grateful for, because I am still breathing. But I go on. I don’t know how but I will find joy and blue skys or parts of them again. I may not remember names, or faces, or what I did two days ago, or what city I am in. I may find it hard to breath, I may find it hard to talk. I may spend all of my money giving away things because even if I can’t feel it, I can remember what a pleasant surprise felt like, what it felt like to know someone cared. Because I will not go gentle into that good night. There is nothing good about it, and I will not wait for it.

I will not let grief dictate me any more than I have let the other pain I have endured dictate me. But I will also not let people ignore it. Grief is part of me, and that is not only normal, if I didn’t have it, it would be abnormal. But I will start again, maybe only a day at a time, if that is what I can remember.

Here again is that anime EF: a story of memory, about a girl who has a memory of one day – each day she reads her journal or repeats what she wants to remember. When she is angry she can simply slip into the timelessness of “Today”; or rip out pages of her journal. Because most of her life no one came for her either. It is a short music video, and it is about pain and grief and how it cannot be stopped; that you cry; but then, because you can’t stop the crying, you stand in the rain. Then at least you LOOK like everyone, or you can make choices where people look beyond the crying.
I cannot control if someone will come FOR me, care FOR me. I cannot control whether I will recognize Linda towards the end or simply live each minute in pain and terror. I cannot control that. But I can control how I act today and start again, and do things to say to people, to Linda and others, “I’m here for you, you are not alone.” I made that dedication in my book, and have lived my life so that if at all possible, someone like me would never again have to exist in this world.

And to have that happen, someone WOULD come, that someone WOULD care. That this cycle of terror, abuse, pain, and distancing, pretending that nothing is happening while the person suffers alone will end with me. I will not live to see that happen I fear. But this isn't a 'world' but a world which is made up of individuals: some lonely, alone, abused, terrified, bruised, individuals. Please be there for someone. Please stop pretending that these things don’t exist, even if you don’t know what to say, say that.

If you can do that, you will be giving me something which I am incapable of giving myself: hope.

29 comments:

cheryl g said...

I have just read this blog and yesterdays and I am grieving for you. You are sellng your books which is like giving up more pieces of you and that has to hurt in its own way.

I regularly alternate between grief and hope these days. I grieve that someone who has become so important to me and truly a sister is going to leave my life much too soon. I hope that we can find something to help and give you more time. I hope that we can get someone to truly provide pain relief.

and then I pray... a lot...

No matter what happens I will be here for you, for Linda. I have made my solemn vow that I will not abandon you.

I love you Sis

Devi said...

I'm not avoiding or ignoring your grief as much as, indeed, not knowing what to say. That, and sometimes it's just that (for lack of a better way of putting it) I don't want to rub it in. As in, I know that you're dying, that you're in pain, but I don't want to talk about you, to you, in terms of you being a terminally ill person because it would feel rude to reduce you to that. (And because I don't want to spoil your hope, your joy in what life and will to live you still have, for that matter.)

Of course your illness is a huge part of your life that's always there (the elephant in the room, if you will), and (as I said) I'm not ignoring it, but you're not just that illness. You're still an entire person with feelings and things to do and say, and I wouldn't want to describe you as "that dying woman."

Doesn't mean I don't respect your grief, or that I'm idealising you as "amazing, strong Elizabeth" and expect you conform to that image at all times. At least I'm trying not to. Even Yuna cried (to tie this into my recent reply.) I respect grieving, human, in-pain Elizabeth just as much as amazing, beautiful Elizabeth.

I know this (allowing myself to get emotionally attached to someone I know is dying) puts me in for a hard ride, but you deserve not less. And nothing would be more human.

Laura said...

Another of your exceptional blogs. I know that dark road all to well though. I need to collect myself before I comment any further at the moment. Bravo! Bravo Beth ah I mean Dr. Elizabeth McClung.

Love and Hugs,
Laura

FridaWrites said...

I'm having a difficult time with comments vanishing on me--I hope this one gets through.

Some days I walk that upper dark road too. I don't know what that upper road will bring. I've given up not just my job but a lot of my hobbies too. That hurts, I grieve. I'm tired of being "brave" and "inspirational." I'm tired too of not being good enough, not being well enough, even as I push myself to do more.

The dedication you wrote for Zed is beautiful.

I am touched that you attach my name to a day of the week, whether or not you remember details at specific times, you have also touched my life greatly, in so many ways. I'd never have started my own blog without yours, and without your lovely responses to my comments.

yanub said...

Ok, Beth. I spent a lot of time on a reply, but then deleted it. Why? Because I would have to spend even more time on it to finish it and I am just plain tired. Sorry, but you want more of me than my brain can deliver this week. It isn't that I don't care. It's that I'm tired and I hurt and I am just not patient and thoughtful when I am tired and hurting. I still have things to do before I can go to bed, and I just spent an hour on a reply that I can't finish because it won't be good enough. So, all I can tell you is that I'm sorry, and that you mean a lot to me, and that I wish things were different. Sorry I suck tonight when you need more. I really wish I could give it. I might be more cogent and useful some other time. Or not. I can't even promise anything. I can't will myself to be clear and helpful and capable of saying the right words just because I wish very, very much that I could. Again, there's the suckage.

Now I am going to pretend that my hands don't hurt, finish my sewing, and go to bed so I can begin the pretending not to hurt again tomorrow. It's OK that you are beyond pretending. I cherish your honesty. It's why I come here.

Maggie said...

It's not that I want to avoid talking about my own grief, your grief, Linda's grief, Cheryl's grief, or anyone else who knows or reads your blog, it just seems so obscene; like I'm somehow hijacking your blog to talk about how I feel about your feelings, or my feelings about you leaving this world way to early (and wondering why it couldn't be a whole list of other people who are so much more deserving). Then I feel guilty because it's not about me, it's about you. So, it's usually better for me to not focus on the grief, but on something else that you've written about.
Besides, sometimes it also seems a little cruel to always ask, "so, are you dying today?" I would find so many other ways to describe you to my friends other than my terminally ill friend, so I imagine, you get a bit tired of always talking and defining yourself as the terminally ill friend.
Anyway, my two cents worth. I'm off to bed, lots of love. I wish I could buy your books so you knew they were going to a new, loving home.

Raccoon said...

Grief I understand.

How to talk about grief, I don't.

My father died in January 94. Metastasized breast cancer. I was sitting beside him when he took the oxygen nose clips off and went to sleep.

I still feel sad. I don't think I started giving voice to my grief until four or five years later. I mean, I cried during that time, but...

I've had more than one pet die. My cats are like children, and people who aren't cat people, people who think animals are just animal, don't understand.

And 11 years and six months ago, I died. Figuratively speaking; the person I was, the physicality that was me, was no more.

And yet, I was still there.

It took me three years before a friend helped me realize that I hadn't been grieving, just bottling everything.

I still grieve for the me that is no more, but the pain is lessened.

I think that people of British extraction (I would say European, but I think other cultures deal with it differently) have problems expressing grief. Problems talking about grief. I think that we are taught that grief is to be expressed privately.

And it's even harder to express when the person that you are grieving for is still alive.

Is it because it's a reminder of our own mortality? But for the grace of xxxxxxx, there go I?

Awkwardness abounds. You try to censor everything that comes out of your mouth, trying to avoid the faux pas...

Heh. Pandora opened a chest, and let all sorts of bugly-uglies out. But at the bottom of the chest, at the end of the day, was still Hope.


So, after all of that rambling, let me finish with this one question:

Who is the striptease for?

Elizabeth McClung said...

Cheryl: a litte pain relief would be a nice thing. It has been a fight, every day to get out of bed; not as in wanting to stay in bed but can I actually raise my head and pull my legs over the side of the bed. Some afternoons it takes 10 minutes, longer.

I am selling the books I gave my grandfather. I am selling the books I stored for researching, I am selling the books on the Hindenburg and other airships. Yeah, it sucks. I am sorry; it seems that I am like a curse, that only knows how to bring pain to the people I care about. I don't want you to be in any more pain.

I am sorry I was so blunt in the post, it is just....everyone leaves. Everyone. But I think you might come back...after your spy training.

Devi: I appreciate your sensativity, it is just sometimes, it crashes like a wrecking ball through our lives, Linda and I and that is all there is. There isn't anything else and people sort of stand around whistling looking into the air. What is up there that must be so facinating?

We want to know every little detail of birth, but we don't want to know anything about death. Well, if you have any questions class, speak now, becuase I'm only going to demonstrate this once!

I guess in a way I feel I am losing my identity, my gender, my orientation, this gaping maw which consumes everything - what am I besides dying, what do I do besides endless check that my lungs are working, heart working, tempature is correct, sleep is correct, etc? I don't know. They never covered that in lesbian 101. My education was stripped as soon as I was in the chair.

I always said that I wanted to be a person that if you shaved my head and dropped me naked in a concentration camp, they would KNOW who I was. Can I still be that?

Thanks. We do what is hard, because it is what is right. That is the true potential of humans.

Laura: thanks for reading. I'll be here (well, I'll probably be asleep, but you know what I mean).

Fridawrites: I am VERY sorry that your comments are vanishing, I have taken to making a copy of all comments in hopes when they vanish, I can reclaim them!

Your second paragraph, yeah, not a very good couple of months. Not at all. A fast road. And like you said, the farther down we fall the more we seem to do. I can't understand it - I work from the minute I wake up until I sleep and yet I am always behind. Always.

Frida! I dont think it is Fridawritesday yet though. It is somewhere in the lost zone. I am glad that made you happy. It also happens to be useful!

As for inspirational, I think I might have killed my 'inspirational' status with the last two posts, darn it.

Maggie: sometimes the only way to tell somewhere we are there is to speak even of ourselves. I remember telling my grandfather of the ships I had seen or the animals watched. I was talking about the things he liked, trying to find a common ground in a time that was difficult for him.

Sometimes what I do that isn't grief is a triumph of pushing through it, sometimes it is an extention, so it appears (to me) that people are avoiding the subject by altering it to something else entirely. Linda said that about yesterday's blog, that people picked the guys comments, and I said, it was the same topic as the rest of the blog. But then, that just shows I am doing a pretty crap job of tying things together. I tried harder today, I did. Of course, burning houses tends to make people go; gosh, she seems a bit, off today. Haha. not really, when you hear of a most of Victoria in flames, THAT would be an off day.

I wish I could give you the books maggie but they are going to an antiquarian faire and I don't think you could afford them. This is the problem with really rare books - where DO you sell your first edition of black beauty? Now I don't have that, but I do have a lot of first editions of famous books or books where only 1 or 2 copies outside of museums might exist and how do I get the value that Linda will need? It takes time, effort and energy - for example, there is a butterfly book from 1895 - looks normal, turns out it is some exceptional text with the first appearance of butterfly X - About $1000. Do I sell it for $12 to someone for a kid who like butterflies - where exactly does one FIND a butterfly book auction?

Raccoon: Thanks. I know. Cats are like children. But then for those of us who for 12 years haven't been able to keep a cat, other things have to substitute. And people don't get that either.

Thank you for talking. About your father. About the you and the not you. I barely have time to register the new me, before I get hit again with another whammy much less grieve. What would I give up, to stand in another epee competition, brain racing, flicks of blade tips, the brain racing? Almost anything. I dream about it, I fantasize about it. I dream of practicing in my chair to hit the ping pong ball. I can't hold a full gatorade and I am going to hold a 5lb + blade? Sorry, this is too painful for me to go on about. Ouch, didn't think the scab was so thin.

I don't know, like I said, we don't do well. I think the whole situation is a little fucked up - I learn to be a nicer person and die - what? What the hell is that about? I don't believe in an afterlife. I don't WANT heaven.

Oh, the striptease is for me - you know the Joy of anticipating beautiful things!

SharonMV said...

Dear Beth,
I'm sorry that I didn't acknowledge your grief over having to sell your books. Books used to be a very big part of my life too. I didn't have many valuable ones, but they were of great value to me. When we moved to our present house. I took a special box down with me in the car - containing my huge Greek lexicon & some other special books. But I've changed some over the years - lost some of my intellectual side. Now there are probably other things that I would save first in a fire.

I'm also sorry if I haven't acknowledge your grief over the many losses you've had. I know we have talked about this before - how painful it is to lose parts of your self. I don't know how I would deal with what your going through. I don't want to leave Dennis or this life, I know you don't want to leave Linda. I know the feeling of being at the end of endurance, of feeling so much emotional pain that you scream & scream inwardly. And I know the realization that there is no one to hear me, no one to help me - there is only myself to deal with this pain.
Dearest Elizabeth, if I could, I would come for you & save you & make it all stop. It grieves me beyond measure that I cannot. But I can love you & offer my hand in the darkness, to hold yours.

Sharon

Gilly said...

Very touching blog, Beth.

Elizabeth McClung said...

Gilly: There are only a few people who would call me Beth; who are you? And how are you touched?

Sharon: Yes, there are books I move on from too, those are okay, but then you starting going to the bone. Ack.

Thank you for your clear description of what I meant (I only took I think an extra 2000 words to say it), yes, the screaming, and no one will come, until the world is only half sane, and you have to go on anyway.

We will meet; I believe this, and I don't believe in another world; I can grieve and hang on, and I can grieve and still be competitive - I will keep my end, you keep yours!

Anan said...

There is only one consolation. If one has truly lived, one will grief life. If one has loved somebody there will be grief and loss.

If things matters one will miss them.
If there would be no pain in loosing thing or people, well then one hasn't really cared.

Grief and loss can be like a screaming hole. Just plunge in and it will almost drown you but just almost.

Anna said...

sorry not anan but Anna

thea said...

Yes grief is grief and loss is loss.

If you shaved your head and got dumped in a concentration camp and mutilated and physically unrecognizable... yes there is a lot of Elizabeth still there. A lot of spark, a lot of life that doesn't depend on being a cheerleader, a champion, a success by any corporate world standards. You would absolutely BE there.

The rawness... I would like to be around to do anything possible to make it less raw, less intense, less whatever is hurting. Because I don't feel the sensations you feel, but every time you write here, I feel grief, partly for the bit that I know you, partly for Linda and Cheryl and their grieving and loss, and I have learned to care for them - and I deeply respect people who do what they have proved they can do - and I feel grief because I feel a sense of loss of someone I could have had more time to get to know, too. So there are all sorts of it. And that's just my limited experience.

I feel for you intensely over your books. I don't collect the way you have done, but I have my own intensities and yes, I do see books as a genuine love and therefore a genuine potential loss to be grieved and mourned, as entities in their own right together with their significance to the person, and everything they could have meant or been for a person. For you. In your loss.

I want for you to find these things easier; I want for you to have better control over the pain - whichever pain... I wish these things for you very much.

JaneB said...

Hi Beth/Elizabeth/friend,

where exactly does one FIND a butterfly book auction?
I do know a couple of natural history book specialists and could ask if you like? It's probably worth it in terms of extra income generated.

Selling books must be awful, I find it hard enough to part with tatty paperback novels, never mind my few beloveds (none of which are as valuable as yours, I've tended to go for quantity as being the kind of person who can read 6-8 full length novels or 3-4 full length non-fiction books in a day I am definitely a mass consumer of the printed word - and my field has only been around for a century or so so I don't have the 'it's for my research' excuse/justification to buy the real beauties).

But... I've grieved over books not returned from loan, it must hurt so much to have to make these choices. I guess the only positive is that to have loved these books you must have lived richly, must have known longing and passion and the fierce joy of getting to touch and to temporarily be the custodian of something special. Certainly with my few old books, I see myself as a custodian rather than an owner - they will pass on to other hands either because I need the money, I have other reasons to cut back on my possessions, or I grow or change to a point where they need to go (which is not to say that I won't make a childish, pathetic scene and resist powerfully when the time comes. I will!! I mean... books!). Life is change - grieving is about letting go and facing up to change. And you've had so MUCH change, it's not surprising you're grieving.

Perhaps I can also say something about loss, about losing a pet as that's something that happened recently to me - and through a rapid degenerative illness too. It was a horrible experience, but it was the cost of sharing my life for five lovely years with a dear, independent, feisty little personality, and the experience of loving that cat, of living with that cat is one I would not want to be without, even as I grieve her still. The only way to avoid grief is to avoid feeling, reaching out, sharing - living. And I'd rather feel the pain than not have had the joy at all. But oh, it's so real and massive and it has vicious claws that get you at the most unexpected of moments.

As Maggie said (maybe this is my Britishness too), it feels self-indulgent to mention my grief and pain at your pain, to go on about empathy and 'feeling for you' when how CAN I possibly, when my life is so different, when ultimately I can imagine, a little, but not know. And am afraid to imagine because I live so much of my life these last few years on a grey and cloudy autumnal road - beauty, exquisite sadness, a shrinking of resource, and the constant fear of slipping into the deep mud and having to fight for any movement. And trying to imagine where you are, whilst in an awful way a comfort - at least through your writing I know, I truely know that other people ride these sorts of emotional rollercoasters - is also both itself a push towards the mud and a cause of guilt - how dare _I_ suffer when you have so much more to bear, and still keep going?

But... I come here and I read and I think of you. I can't be there to hold your hand literally due to inconvenient geography, but I listen, think, pray for you and for Linda and for Cheryl, incoherantly hoping that things will stabilise, that at least there will be a ledge on your wild ride where you can catch your breath and research the definitive guide to human-squirrel psychologies and get some more joy and sunshine. I hope for that ledge for you, and for me and for all of us. A place where we can care, and be, without the daily petty niggling detail and worry that grinds away at everything.

I don't know what to say. And even if I have a feeling I want to share, I'm pretty lousy at putting it into words. I will write such an angry, grieving, rejoicing poem one day about the experience of knowing you, but... today I have to write classes and not cry at the office and hope to sleep more than a couple of hours tonight so I can get up and do it all again with a smile on my face tomorrow.

With love, and gratitude for knowing you, and empathy

Abi said...

I'm sorry - I only have the vaguest beginnings of an understanding of what it is that you and Linda are going through at the moment. "I don't know what to say" is effectively my catchphrase, so perhaps I should use it more often. It's just that it gets a bit tedious after a while.

I feel very unhappy that I currently get to do so much, while you do not. I often feel that I am rubbing your face in it when I talk about what I am doing, but you asked me to, and I cannot just cut you off because I am doing things you can't do. I cut you off anyway, but that is due to my own ineptitude and is not intentional.

You are very demanding, you know. You insist that we must step outside our comfort zones and do something to make a difference. Then you insist some more; you are persistent. The world is a better place because you are alive and demanding. Thank you.

And now I have strayed off-topic. I am sorry that your life is such that you are grieving, and I am sorry for your grief. I am sorry for not being brave enough to confront your grief without explicit prompting; I will try harder next time. I am here, listening, and am always trying to be more for you.

Sending more gentle hugs your way.

Lene Andersen said...

Giving up your books. Oh, no. The pain of that is unimaginable. The grief of that and the grief of losing all the people who care about you. I am "just" losing you and having a hell of a time adjusting to that, but you are losing many people, many things that were your life.

I will come for you. I can't take you away, but I can be there with you, every step of the way down your path, I can talk and listen about the grief until you have to fly away. And I will continue to come for people who need it, whenever I can, for as long as I can.

SharonMV said...

Dear Beth,
I'm working on keeping my end of our bargain. Making some progress. Have to endure going to another specialist to help with the adrenal problem. then I'll have more strength & energy & will be able to apply my full "grit & determination". Look out world when that happens.

Sharon

Kita (Gilly) said...

Beth, sorry to spook you, I am Kita, just using my first name for a change. Sorry again.

You speak of grief and you are quite correct, it is a very little talked about reaction. I have known and lived with grief for so long, my kids being taken into care literally broke my heart. I felt that broken glass around my heart and I have had the fortune to have travelled that road. Fortunate because I have, through pure stubbornness stayed here. And even though there were the hrs, days weeks of nothing but blackness, I stayed. As do you. Now, well, I can hold my head up. Just. I have come to terms with loss, but my hope is my kids come back to me. It is nothing I am certain of, but I understand grief and joy.

I'm not that sure what I'm trying to say, I seem to be rambling here. I think you are a wonderful person. And I thank you that you stayed.

Veralidaine said...

Yes, I freely acknowledge that grief is on the list of things I do not understand how to talk about, along with love, sexuality, depression, weakness, and fear. It seems I always miss the social cues that say "Now is an okay time to talk about your feelings!" or I burst out with a story about grief having missed a social cue of "It is happy time, no sad allowed!"

I know grief, we've met a few times, but I don't understand it, and no, I don't cope with it when it happens to me very well at all. I build walls in my head to keep it away, or it gets to me and I scream and cry and drink too much and punch the wall and the other stuff that you know about (read back in your email if your brain erased that and you would like to know what I told you) but that I don't feel comfortable saying publicly.

It is hard for me that I know how much you mean to me and that I will lose you. I don't know how I will cope with that grief. I am still not done grieving the loss that happened in my life on August 31, 2006. I've gone from it hurting every day to thinking about it every day but having a wall built up so it doesn't hurt, but then feeling guilty because I think I am not honoring her memory enough and I know I am shielding myself from things that remind me of her.

No. I don't know what to say. I try to say that often so you know I'm not saying the wrong thing on purpose, I just don't know. I don't like to talk about my grief.

I will tell you a short story that is very hard for me to type out-- I wouldn't even tell my SO what I was upset about, although he guessed and I nodded.

Last weekend my niece had her first horseback riding lesson. Over a year ago my first horse, who I had since sold to a little girl who loved her more than life itself, died unexpectedly and much too young. My sister brought my niece for the riding lesson and found out from the instructor that my horse had died. She then told our parents, who I'd never told because it just hurts too much to tell. I couldn't even look at them after that. I just said "I don't want to talk about it," and walked away. I'm tearing up typing it, too. That horse saved my life twice and I don't want anyone even knowing she's gone because then they'll know I hurt and they'll look at me differently and they won't understand and they'll try to make it better but it won't get better and it will just remind me and hurt all over again...

I am sorry about the books. I can't imagine how hard it must be to have to choose which ones to part with. I hope they all find loving homes with people who understand what they meant to you. I do not have any possessions that are that meaningful to me (not counting my pets as possessions, they are more like fuzzy children) but I think the thing that would be hardest to lose would be the one CD I have that has a video of the person I lost in 2006 talking. I can't watch it because it makes me cry too much but it gives me some comfort just to have it.

Gaina said...

I can't think of anything useful or appropriate to say in response so I'll just send you my biggest, warmest hug and say 'I hear you'.

I do things for the now, to enjoy the moment. And if those moments carry on, and what I am learning and enjoying today benefits me in a year or two? Well that's great, but that's not the point, it's what gives me pleasure right now that really matters. Lots of happy moments NOW are what everyone should live for, not just people with chronic illness or disability.

Ms.Pet said...

I think Incest can best be described as "the grief that never ends." We start grieving at an early stage: for the loss of innocence, the protection that wasn't there, the parents, family, society that wasn't there, for not having a safe place to run to, for not knowing what "trust" is, having no examples of it, for not having "parents" like we're told that "Normal" folks have, and so on. For knowing that the minute we speak our truth, those we love will abandon us, preferring to see us as "the crazy one," rather then the whole family and themselves and so on...grief for the hope we continue to have that our reality will be validated and the loss we experience over and over again. And of course, there's the grief of never having experienced safety in our childhood lives, and not having twenty years of feeling that in our bodies, knowing what it is, having to learn it, explore it in adulthood.

I understand what the loss of ability is like, and the grief process one goes through, as Fibromyalgia is also a state of chronic grief. You lose, then you gain back ability for a certain period, "feel better," only to lose it again and experience the loss all over again. Grief and disability go hand in hand. Lovers, one could say.

I can't know what it's like to lose ones life or even more apt, to go through what you are experiencing, which is a chronic state of losing ones life, bit by bit, VS getting hit by a car and it being gone, *snap* no feeling, no awareness. I'm not going to say, "it's okay," or anything smaltzy like that, because it isn't "Ok," but I will say that it's OK TO GRIEVE and thank you for being willing to share it openly, with us. I know you can't talk about it 24/7 and who could? But...well, I'll say it now, while you can still read it...

I will miss you when you are gone. I will miss your posts even though, I don't read them very often now, or anyone elses. And I thank you for being there for me, for encouraging me to use my voice, for defending my right to speak my truth irregardless of whether it "offends" those of the status quo, the "appropriate" and "correct" folks. It meant and means the world to me, as most would rather silence the voices of those on the margins, then encourage them to speak their truth, most would rather closet them. And so, you have made a difference in my life, and I want you to know that. Because too often we don't tell this truth out loud to those who make the difference. "Thank you," is a simplistic expression of gratitude, but it's an honest one.

I don't read my emails, I've developed a SERIOUS phobia, and don't read blogs that often anymore. I don't know exactly why. I have about six hundred emails waiting for me. I wanted you to know that, so you didn't think I wasn't responding to anything you might have written in response to the email I sent you. ANyways, I AM on MSN, if you can use that. Just add me, I have you, but I don't see you on much. If not, well, hopefully, I'll find the strength to face the email soon, and your number will be there and I can call you. *pause*

I worry about the day when I return to your blog, only to find...there are no more posts being written and the finality that this will mean. I hope your partner is able to keep it up, but understand if she can't.

You are much loved. You are not alone. Well, in a sense, I guess you are, but there are millions bearing witness as you walk this path, and though we might not always be there, every day, we are there, as much as we can be.

I wish I'd been well enough to come and see you before I moved. I wish you were well enough to come and visit here. Thank you for talking about your grief, it allows us the opportunity to be present in your life. *gently wraps a blanket around you, and starts to brush your hair.*

Ms.Pet said...

Re: Hope

YOu know, there's a saying on the streets that I heard a long, long time ago, "Hope is Addictive." I've been thinking about that alot, with the whole Audacity of Hope - Obama thing.

Hope is what keeps one going, when there is no reason to continue on, what keeps one alive, more so then even water or food and shelter.

Re: books

When I moved to BC I left all my books in Montreal, gave them all up aside from a couple. It was the worst mistake of my life, I suffered so much, not having my books around me, they ground you, and when they are gone, it's like part of that which grounds you, is gone to. Or that's what it was like for me. So...it's not weird to greive the loss of books, for each book is a voice of a human being, that is crying out to be heard.

i'm sorry, i can't write short for the life of me, and i'm too tired to struggle with editing, mentally and cognitively tired I mean.

Neil said...

You've given up your business clothes, and now you're giving up books. I grieve with you about their loss; it's hard to give up any book, much less many treasured books that may have sentimental value that far outweighs their financial worth. I do understand that grief, and I share it with you.

You're angry, and that's completely understandable, Beth. Scream? You scream in pain nearly every day, I gather. Doesn't help much... But you're screaming in print with this entry, and I hear and understand that scream. Such an eloquent rage it is, too.

I tell you again, sweetie, you HAVE made a difference to me, and difference IN me. It pleases me to think that I am a better person for having met you, even if it's only online.

Of course you should order a pair or two of jeans; you don't know WHEN you'll be bedridden, and you'll still need clothes, 'cause sure as hell the doctor's and other appointments won't stop just because you are stopping. Beacon will probably want an interview after you've died, just to find out from you why you don't need their services any more!

I don't know if I will be here for anyone else, but I am here for you; you are in my mind now and always. I hope for you, I pray for less pain for you, I wish for you good days and nights. I think of you manymany times each day. I care about you, Beth. And I see you caring for others, trying to bring hpe and joy to us even though there's none for you. Surely that makes you a far, FAR better human than most of us.

And yes, I love you, Niece,
Neil

cheryl g said...

Sis, stop apologizing to me! You are not hurting me. Having you in my life is a gift beyond price.

Tammy said...

when it comes to dealing with grief, I am completely self destructive. I was raised to not "make a scene", and keep it all inside. I am glad you are trying to change the way people think, talk, deal, and communicate about grief.
Your grief is so deep, it's touchable, tangible, visible. It's hard to know what to say to you. I so wish I did know what to say, but I just don't.
I can just read your blog, cry, and feel helpless. I care so very much but I don't know what to do. I'm so terribly sorry. I am worthless when it comes to grief.

Nancy said...

Thank you for this post--I wanted to write and say that it impacted me. We definitely bury grief in our culture, and we shouldn't. There are so many eloquent things that have already been said, and I don't think I'll be able to say anything new or profound. But I just wanted to say that I'm thinking about you, and trying to keep solidarity with you in your grieving.

Elizabeth McClung said...

Anna: true, it seems the measure of loss it a ratio of openness to hurt. Interesting point.

Thea: I do feel frustration because I want to tell the truth but on the other hand, as you point out, the sensations are too far out of normal for most people to experience, too raw, too intense, too much feeling helpless (which is what we feel too, though, maybe I should say that more often, the most common feeling is helplessness). And yet, I AM running out of time.

Pain control=good - maybe help me get some joy back, maybe help me forget that end of days, and enjoy the days that are here - that would be very good.

Jane B: I do see myself as a custodian, which is why many or some of my books I passed on, special dedication copies between Vernon Lee (a Victorian writer) and her lesbian lover; a couple books in museums. I just can't make sure that a book which was safe for 100-400 years before me will end up in perfect condition so I tend to sell of special leather bindings or other rarities and replace them with reading copies. However, when the only copy made WAS 50 of them 150 years ago, then well, what do you do? It is irritating when my "reading copy" is worth about $700+. And I haven't READ IT YET!

Yes, I am very sorry for your loss, and the more the personality, the harder it is not to be reminded of that loss. And grief does strike in strange places, thinking, "X would like this" and then realizing that they won't see it, that they are gone.

To live fully, and openly will result in grief. To live any other way - will result in something worse I think. For me, it is too late to start being prudent emotionally, don't you think?

I fully believe what Cheryl says, that pain is pain; and that suffering is suffering, and that loneliness and isolation is just that, and can be almost unbearable. I told Linda tonight, I am so burned out I would be trying to kill myself if I didn't have so much to do first! I shouldn't joke, and it wasn't one. What I mean is, the more I suffer, the more I realize how important it is to lighten the suffering of others in any way imaginable. Which is why I do postcards and presents as I can.

But also why I try to set up a dialogue so that people can talk about things like grief, and not BE alone with it. What right have you to complain, every right! What right have I to complain? There is always someone suffering more. Or rather, my suffering enlightens me because I don't have the soul numbing depression that goes with this pain. And so I want to be with those who do, because I know that. That is suffering. This is just dying, rather splatacularly.

I have to go sleep more now too - Linda is vexed, and I have duties for tomorrow as well. Take care.

Abi: You have just figured that out? I am exceeding demanding. Do you know how I met Cheryl - now I remember. She said, she couldn't play a sport. I said, come over and I will prove you wrong. I push limits. Because I love you and I want to see you fly. And I don't want to push you further than you can bear - so if I am, tell me okay.

And why not tell me the good things that happen. I WANT good things to happen to people I like. I mean, you aren't so keen on your job and what if I got better and got some great Uni teaching gig - should I not tell you becuase I would be rubbing it in your face. No way, we would rejoice together!

And truth be told Abi, sometimes I just need to hear someone talking, or listen to something in the darkness to keep me from screaming, from the weight of it pressing down on me. I need to know that people will still speak to me, that life goes on OUT THERE, that there is happiness and joy still. You do me a favor.

Lene: Yeah, we better hurry up - well you said you wanted to talk about suffering, and now I've started without you.

The books are priced and ready to go to other homes, some more to price tomorrow. A lifetime of work chipped away. Oh well. Maybe we can make enough for a little time away.

Sharon: little by little, I hold on, and you take it little by little, no sudden moves, and setbacks okay. I am waiting. I will hold on.

Kita: thank you, I got a bit freaked there.

Thank you for talking. The blackness around that statment about your children being taken into care makes me feel dark, and for you, for so long working, waiting. Yes, I don't know how to make that better but thank you for sharing and letting me know. See, now I am the one without the right words. I don't want to open up a wound. But I think it aches a bit all the time anyway. I know about that. But not yours. Thank you again for talking.

Veralidaine: I know how important your animals are to you, and I can understand the loss like that; I am sorry, and just thinking about it or reading it makes me tear up. Love and caring, and watching the people and things we love and then losing them is a horrible process. And yet, we did HAVE love, we did love, we did care. And I know that if she (?) was your horse, then there wasn't another horse who was loved more. Or knew more love. Who experienced it.

I am sorry for your losses, and for the person you have lost. Thank you for talking. I am sorry that I cannot continue, but I can't. Not right now.

Queen Slug said...

I don't know why we aren't taught to talk about grief, why we aren't taught that grief is something will will have in our lives & how to offer words to comfort (not bullshit "I'll pray for you" or "I know this is happening for a reason"), but really comfort people.

<3