The Olympics is an event of amateurs.
Now that may shock or anger some people but it is the truth. The Olympics was never recreated over 100 years ago as anything other than a place where amateur athletes, people who practice in the early morning, or after work, gather to strive for the love of their sport and individual best. Of course, the Olympics was originally stated that women shouldn’t be involved and though unsaid, likely that non-white shouldn’t show up either. This was for the “boys” of Yale and Oxford, McGill, Cambridge, Harvard and some of the best of Europe and Australia would meet; kind of like the regattas, that “sports” spirit.
Now of course with some countries giving money for medals, some of that has disappeared but I can assure you that most of the world’s countries including Canada are not lavishing money on athletes (you are lucky if they are paying your airfare!). Nor will these athletes be ending training when Olympics finish, but rather going on to another competition, a world cup or another amateur event in a few weeks. When I fenced or trained with some of the women who are at the Olympics, they did not receive money for winning tournament X or even the nationals. Yes, eventually they would get a “Card” which would give them about 40% of the money needed to make the tournaments they needed to just in Canada (know what a round trip to Regina costs?). In my salle, The three time National Champion, winner of the Pan-Am Games and winner or bronze medalist of the Commonwealth games (which only happen once every few years, much like the Student games), was not only going to university but also working part time at the clothing store The Gap – and doing 4+ hours of training a day. That is considered being an Amateur. When you are paid a salary like pro (like “professional”) hockey, basketball, baseball, soccer/football, American football or even boxing or triathlons you are a professional. So when the boxer from Zimbabwe shows up at the Olympics, there will NOT be Mike Tyson facing him (I say he because women still can’t box at the Olympics). That determines the arenas you compete in; are you going pro or not? (For some sports like fencing or archery we only WISH there was a professional circuit like the golfers have!).
So, while this is a highly televised and publicized and in many ways overly nationalized competition, it is still the same small group of archers or fencers or badminton singles players. And yeah, it sucks to get knocked out at the Olympics but they will be facing each other again in next month’s European Cup. And while commentators may present it all as a do or die, a single event people train for, for “elite” amateur athletes, it is another competition on the schedule and yeah, you train at other events FOR going to the Olympics (or the Pan Am games), but now, if you want to be back in four years, you and your coach are focusing on the next tournament. Now I never made it to that level, but it was my three year goal. When I went into the wheelchair I was already qualified for the next Nationals. I was planning to go to the Canadian Westerns, to add to my Canadian points, and then do the North America Cup series in Group II this time and see if I could get in the top 32, and then do Group I the following year (for US points – the two countries won’t accept each other’s points).
I’m not saying that to say, “I could have been there!” Haha, I wanted to be 25th in Canada and maybe 35th or so in the US, that was my goal. To get up in the top 12, to compete for team spots, that’s for people younger than me (like 17 year olds), I just loved the sport and wanted to be up where I could face and fence the best, the people better than me, to learn and to push my limits. But at the same time, when a person with a disability in the US (ANY disability: from autism to quadriplegics) are three times more likely to be sedentary than the population, and when the majority of people with disabilities engage in no physical activity at all, I am concerned. I am worried that people with disabilities think that it is the Olympics, or Paralympics or nothing. Or that there isn’t anything they can do.
I was not watching Olympics tonight because I was too busy BEING an amateur athlete to watch other amateur athletes. I was up at Badminton, and I only managed to fall over going for a birdie once tonight (and one save when I was going over). It is recorded that females with disabilities have even less opportunity than males with disabilities, at the Paralympic games females only comprise 25% of the athletes. But then not a lot of women are drawn to wheelchair rugby. At the winter Paralympics that falls to 20%. Now, I am not saying, “Go for the Paralympics!” but it does reflect a trend, and yeah, for a lot of us, getting out of bed IS our sport. I am not boxing anymore, and I don’t think I can call myself a wheelchair boxer, though I might give it one more try, but I am already trying to find a way to join the disability swim team. Janet the coach says, “We haven’t worked out the problem of how you are going to swim with oxygen!”
I said, “See, that is the distance I swim, one length, and the OXYGEN is the incentive, if I make it to the other side, I get the oxygen, otherwise I pass out in the water!”
She laughed and said she would “think about that.”
Look, I know a lot of people are unable to do physical activity and others have no desire to, and I don’t make judgements in my mind one way or another. But if someone WANTS to do an activity, from belly dancing, to a swim class, to wheelchair judo or BADMINTON (sorry, couldn’t help that!), then I want them to be able to do that. And I want them to understand that there are not two classifications, there is amateur athlete. It is just the level of commitment, and that is a personal choice (some of us like to spend extra time kissing Linda).
Anyway, talking about getting out and about, Cheryl came over and we went to Mount Doug park to have a picnic.
Which was nice, to see trees and hear the sounds of birds (a heron flew by), rather than….roofers!And for those who don’t understand when I say I turn green, here is a picture, not as green as when I went to the hospital or passed out in the doctors office but an idea of what my hands turn into
(from mottled purple to GREEN) when they get hot, try to sweat and that doesn’t happen.Anyway, I hope you enjoy watching the Olympics and I hope that you also realize that wheeling down to the grocery store IS a form of activity, and for those of us where the route seems harder and harder, an athletic activity. I am flipping through the fall calendar for local activities, whether it be painting or better yet, belly dancing, I am getting out of here and doing something. Yeah, I’m weaker, I’m in more pain, but until breathing becomes my main athletic activity, I am getting OUT THERE. I will keep you all updated.



19 comments:
I think everyone should have the opportunity to do what they want, as long as it is not harmful to others .. of all the ridiculous things our gov't spends money on, I don't understand why they can't devote more to making it easier for disabled people to go out as much as they can and take a bigger slice of life
I am not really watching the Olympics, I am not a huge sports fan in general. But I watched our women's softball team play a couple of games (it's actually a sport I understand) and I watched some of the judo. I never understand what sports are chosen to be played, most of them are just so alien to me; not a judgement call but I just don't get them. I watched a little of the female wrestling, another sport I have some knowledge of. I've known people who have come close to compteting in the Olympics, the amount of sacrfice is pretty amazing .. Whether or not someone is going for a medal we should always encourage people to pursue their dreams because that makes for better people, I think, and the world can always use better people
I am happy to know you have been out and about knocking the wind out of yourself, testing your limits. And, also, you went on a picnic in the park! Wonderful!
You are great at challenging preconceptions, Elizabeth. I know that you do indeed encourage others to be more active, in more ways than athletically.
Victor: I too think that people should have the chance to do what they enjoy; that is part of community and citizenship and shouldn't be denied due to disability.
Also I agree, I hope it didn't seem I was putting down the people who go, or at an Olympic level, because they are following dreams, committing time and effort and doing amazing things (but then I think people who for example edit and make films can go to those levels of following dreams too). But this idea that one day someone shows up after four years of training, it fosters the wrong idea, there were qualifying events to begin with and other events to learn HOW to compete at high levels.
But I agree, that people with passion and who commit to them, and are supported in them make for a better community. Thanks for that perspective.
Yanub: Well, I could hardly comment on the olympics if I wasn't ready to go to the floor a few times myself (won both games by the way.....not that I'm counting!). And finished with some one on one skill training with the best badminton player (from Tawain, was on the Team). Getting out was good too. I will pay for the badminton tomorrow but still, nothing like a well placed counter hit, a groan from the opposing team and a few "Good one" from the people watching on the sides.
I am glad that you went to the beach. And I hope that I do encourage all activity or all intent, and I thought that to write about postcards and then this sort of showed the specrum that I live in, the spectrum of MY athletics - some days it is pushing a pen, or sorting a postcard, some days, if it is a good day, wheeling. And because disabilities are complex, I know people make thier own boundries and thier own activities, and often don't call it sport, or even "active" or "Activity" but that's just words, my background and thiers right, "crafts" or "activity" either way, someone is focused, something is done, the world is better, the person is better. Oh and don't forget BREAD MAKING! Cooking - a major activity!
Good morning! It's good to see you're up and around and outside on a nice day.
Yes, I know how much it costs to fly to Regina; I live there. Here. I also know that sometimes it's cheaper to fly from Calgary to Toronto with a stop in Regina than it is to get on the same plane AT Regina during the stop.
Picnics are wonderful. And you got out to a beautiful place with real trees, and a real friend (as opposed to all of us semi-imaginary ones?) Hi Cheryl! *waves energetically so as to be seen from over the horizon*
I'm not interested in the Olympics this time. They've become a political tool, and that's not what the Olympics movement is supposed to be about. I'll spend my time being outdoors and active
instead of being a sedentary, passive receptor of advertising and demands that I buy products and services that I don't need and/or can't afford.
Belly dancing is good. Go for belly dancing!
I haven't been watching much of the Olympics primarily because I get so annoyed with the sportscasters. They talk about these athletes like one morning they just woke up and were suddenly top competitors. Rarely do they mention the sacrifices made and the difficulties overcome.
For the rest of us I think people need to take more pride in their accomplishments at least in their own minds. Why not think, "I accomplished X (craft, reading, cooking, transferring from bed to chair for awhile) today in spite of my illness/disability. I did great!"
Western society especially seems to have a culture where if you aren't the very best at what you do then you don't get much encouragement. That whole, "They're not a very good athlete/painter/dancer/etc. so why do they waste time/money on that when they could be being productive doing something else."
I think society's emphasis on only doing the useful and practical unless you are super good at something kills a lot of dreams. We need to encourage people to follow their dreams. Your pottery/dancing/cooking/swimming may never win you awards and accolades but do what you love anyway. Doing what you love/enjoy is the reward.
Hmmmm... maybe you should practice kissing Linda more. Seems lieka good reward and you should keep training for the gold medal in that particular skill.
I keep thinking of you with respect to the Olympics. I have no idea whether or not you could have made it (I know there's no way you should have been able to make it, but that's a different issue altogether with you), but I do get a little wistful for what could have been. Bloody life, with its difficulties :-(
Alas, I have nothing profound to say (a day at work does that to me sometimes). It is good that you get out, though. It is great that you share it with us!
Hi: my Beloved used to decide to make bread when Oldest son was i a foul mood. He can't talk about what's bothering him, so she'd ask him to knead the bread dough. That was always a win-win situation: she'd get bread that was punched and keaded to perfection, we'd get great bread, and son would get rid of his frustrations, and eventually would talk about what was bothering him.
Kissingspouses as an Olympic event... I like that. I haven't kissed my Beloved enough lately, 'cause I've been too tired at home. I'll have to get back into the habit of kissing more. Thanks Cheryl!
Zen hugs and cheers,
Neil
I'm best and doing exercise when it's something I really like. I liked using the exercise bike before it bothered my knee, but now it doesn't get used much.
Oddly enough, I finally found my NYC Ballet Workout 2 DVD last night and put it in. I guess it could be depressing how much I can't do now that I could do easily and well 5 years ago, but I was more heartened that there's a lot of it that I can still do! I hurt too much to do it last night but am planning to give it a try again. No jumps for me! This is a lot more interesting to me than PT isometrics, which bore me senseless. Now if they could adapt those isometrics to ballet or swim exercises...
My sister's inaccessible Colorado city actually offers wheelchair yoga, though I don't know how people would get there from their inaccessible houses (maybe there are some older homes there?). They also offer adaptive sports for younger children with various disabilities.
Oh god, this must be the most boring post ever - oh well, new record in low comments. OR did everyone take my advise and go out and do stuff - no, most boring post ever.
Neil: since I don't have a TV, the Olympic mania has passed me by. I however don't have the eloquent vocab you do to denouce it.
I've never understood the costs of going to places in Canada, how I can go to California for $200 or Saskatoon for $800. Hmmm?
Your beloved sounds plenty smart, I will have to try that when Linda gets all frustrated with her feelings too. Heck, I should invite in neighbors, as I need more and more home made bread - still brill idea!
Cheryl: I agree, or it is as if all this person did was train in isolation for four years and after this they are going back to being a janitor in a thermometor factory. No, they had to do competitions, rise through the ranks, all that.
I agree with both your observations, we want things the fast way which I think explains the Western obsession with Geniuses, the whole, "Don't even have to work, they just show up and they are better than everyone" - I do think people should take pride in what they do, and what they participate in. I sang, for a while and I knew I was always a backing, a choir singer, never a soloist, and when I chose an instrument, I chose the same type. It is fun, it is what I am, I don't need to be the first violin who stands up and sways back and forth during a concert. One day, a man stopped me on the street and said, "I wanted to thank you for the orchestra performance." I told him honestly that wasn't my best work but he interupted me and said, "But of all those people, you were the only one who looked like you were enjoying yourself."
I guess it does make a difference.
Abi: if I had gone on single mindedly into epee and competition maybe I could have risen higher, maybe done pan-am or North American cup final, the big leagues. But where are all those people I spent hours a day, every day for weeks and years training with now? Have they sent me a card? Or come to see me. Or commented.
Two road diverged, and one was chosen for me, but becuase of it, I get to meet people like you, and talk to you. So while I miss the highs of competition and the Zen aspects of fencing, to leave the friends I have made and go back to that would only show me what a lonely person I was. That right now is the only "what if" I have.
I've often said if I ran the world all sport would be amateur. Everything gets skewed when it's professional.
I used to think you had to start a particular sport (or musical instrument, etc) at a super young age and dedicate your life to it in order to be elite. Now I know the stories of many athletes are more complex and varied than that. It is possible to take up a new sport and become highly proficient in a relatively short time, just like you have done (more than once, I think).
I am fickle when it comes to watching sports - some years the Olympics captures my attention, sometimes not. Same with soccer world cup, Wimbledon, or Aussie rules football here at home. Overall I'm more dedicated to showing up for my own (usually low-grade) netball, basketball or soccer games for the combination of fitness, striving to WIN, fun, and teamwork. I just think as a society we'd be better off with more people participating in sport (at any level of ability) and less obsession and money riding on the elite few. That's not to say I don't value the brilliance and sacrifice of the elite few!
I have been watching the Olympics. I've had a rough few weeks and my body just doesn't want to go far in the evenings, so I watch them. I am so impressed with some of these athletes. I'm not even that much of a sports minded person, but I do like watching.
To me, my Olympic training is getting out of bed, and getting ready for work. The getting moving is the hard part for me. Once I am started, as long as I don't sit down to stiffen up, I am pretty good, so work is the easy part, the getting there (the vertical and moving faster than a turtle in a coma) that's my Olympic training every morning. lol. Hmmm...I just don't see the "She won a gold for getting to work 5 days a week" medal in my future any time soon.
I'm glad you got out and about. I adore picnics. The green hand, just absolutely freaky! It's like you can see all those little ruptured veins in your hands too. I imagine it is quite painful. I know when my fingers just get some mild discoloration how much they hurt, I couldn't imagine it all the way up to my shoulders. It just doesn't look fun at all.
Glad to read your post..and NOPE, it wasn't boring to me. I hope you just inspired those to get out and about.
BTW...I got some very very cool Hello Kitty Geisha temp. tattoo's from you yesterday. AWESOME!!!! Thank you SO SO much. I had to hide them from my daughter with the promise I would share at least one with her. I think it will be very fun to play "Find the new tat" with Hubby! ;) I have a real tattoo I got a few years ago..there is a story to that too for some other time. Thank you again. I REALLY needed the "pick me up" this week. You have quite the knack for perfect timing and the perfect thing. HUGS.
I'm surprised anyone would be upset at someone saying the Olympics is for amateurs... I didn't know not everyone realized that!
I agree with the activity, though I haven't been up to much since a couple of my newer impairments showed up. I used to go to the gym 3x/week: 1+ hour on aerobic machines, 1+ hour on the weight machines. Had to stop after the Chiari & cervical scoliosis went berzerk -- whenever I did even a short workout, I'd get laid up with spasms & nacrolepsy for days. Now I just do dancing at home.
There's another big reason (in the USA at least) that disabled people don't exercise: financial impact. Being on a severely restricted income often means struggling to afford food at the end of the month, so even spending the $5 to get into a swim center (let alone pay for full-price bus fair or gas) even once is too much of a luxury. There's also that many bus systems have extremely restricted hours to the low-income areas most of us get stuck in, while most activities in society are held at night accommodate people that are busy at work during the day. :-/
If you're looking for new physical activities to try out that is compatible with wheelchair users, you might check out local stables focused on accommodating disabilities. Evidence is mounting (haha) that riding is therapeutic for all kinds of impairments, without requiring the kind of strain that most other forms of exercise does.
With that, I'm trotting off to see when the various equine parts of the Olympics take place, and how I can get copies online from other countries. (We don't have cable TV, and even if we did the USA's coverage of horses always sucks.)
Californian Autistic Lurker-
NBC has been running the Equestrian events on the Oxygen network at 5:00pm Central time. Three day eventing is over so is Jumping and Dressage. I don't know if there are any more.
Laura
I got a postcard at work today. The really cool people all got a kick out of it and wanted to know where you got your stickers. The not-cool people are looking at me with a bit more perplexity than normal. My annoying office mate is actually not bothering me since she saw it. Do you suppose it was the girl with all the knives that gave her pause?
Thanks Sis, you rocked my day!
I think there's are strong connotation (at least in the US) that amateur = not serious, or not having a professional attitude toward the matter at hand.
I vote for Olympic log rolling to be added to the list of approved sports. I was so proud of myself when I took on the hill at the Washington Monument, even though I was sick for hours afterwards with the dizziness.
I vote on a layman's level for more safe, accessible hiking/wheeling areas. The one I use is usually safe (except when it's a fireworks staging area for 2 weeks), but certainly not accessible to people with disabilities, unless loose gravel makes for good wheeling. Since it's a major tailgating (football fan picnics) area, I wonder if they have accessible porta-johns out there... my guess is no. For $20/car parking, they ought to, though.
I look at the American men's basketball team, and I wonder how they are allowed to play! I mean, they all pull down multimillion dollar contracts in the states...
Raccoon: the US made an appeal to the IOC (with LARGE sums of money several years ago to say for certain team sports there weren't enough people who in a 'national' sport weren't in some pro league or another - same arguement made with hockey which is why some teams DO allow pro members - not what I think the intent of the Olympics was about, but then I think when the networks got the winter and summer games split becuase it was costing too much money to cover both in one year, the whole idea of the olympics sort of left. The only thing that hasn't changed are the people from various countries walking around and going to the competitions and glad to be there, even though they know they will be lucky to be 19th in the rankings for thier sport. That hasn't changed thankfully, for all that nations seem to want to have far more say than athletes, and medals are seen as far more important than participation.
For a blog called "Screw Bronze" that might be seen as more than hypocritical, but there is a difference in trying for your personal Gold, or Platnium, for attempting what is beyond you, and failing or succeeding for you (and maybe your friends or those who support you), and the idea that a piece of metal of a medal make one person better than another as a human being.
Yeah, I know. Money talks. I meant my comments in a more rhetorical fashion.
On other topics, I went to a dance on Saturday night. Got all dressed up and everything.
Okay, after 11 years I've only figured out how to do the Grand March and a schottische, but it's a start.
Unfortunately, many pro US athletes (e.g., Kobe Bryant) compete in the Olympics, which (a) irritates the s--- out of me and (b) maybe gives folks the wrong impression of what an "amateur" is.
Post a Comment