Thursday, January 03, 2008

Translucent: a book series for both those with disabilities & those who care about them

If you are a person with a disability or a person who is partnered with, cares for, or cares about a person with a disability I feel that you MUST read the series Translucent (Seriously, these are books you NEED to read). Okay, yes, it is manga, which is a japanese comic style of story telling, but printed in English. "Oh no, a manga!" is going to turn some people off, but I ask you to hold off on your assumptions or feelings of “not for me” until I explain. This series is about a person with a disability and the people around them as they try to fit in, try to find their place in society, fulfill and work towards their dreams, have problems and setbacks but lean on each other and get back up to try again. I know that is something I can relate to, and I think you can too.

Translucent is about an eighth grade girl named Shiroyama and a guy who likes her named Tadami. Only Shiroyama has this new chronic disease called translucent syndrome which makes parts of her (sometimes all of her) literally translucent (or invisible). Through book 1 and book 2 she meets adults who have the same condition and by facing and working through situations and through their advice she struggles to find out what a 'normal' life is like with a chronic condition. So why I am recommending this series so strongly? Because in these books, the disease ‘translucent syndrome’ is really a metaphor for any chronic condition and narrated from both her view and the view those around her. The series is able to address not just what it is like both physically and mentally to have a chronic condition in today’s society, but also the viewpoint of the caregiver, the friend, and the cost to THEM of seeing the person they care about hurt by society (as well as the rewards they get FROM that relationship). Linda read the book and we talked about it, because for her it was able to voice a lot of how she views me; why though I am sure I am a burden and she will leave, she does not see it that way. Book two in the series has more of the adult relationships and goes into exactly what do the caregivers and friends get out of the relationship: why it IS worth it. Okay, now tell me you have found a book or series or movie that depicts you and your life regarding disability in this way. I’m guessing like me, beyond a small handful, you haven’t, because any book on disability is far and few between. That is why I don’t want you to miss this one.

The series (currently published up to book two: available used or in the 3 for 4 offer at Amazon for Book 1 and Book 2 - you can also read the first bit of each book there as well by clicking on “Search Inside”), plainly shows the social attitudes toward people with disabilities. Shiroyama is whispered about, “There is that girl.”, “I wonder what it feels like?” And we see Shiroyama trying SO hard to fit in, to be ‘normal’ (indeed she and another girl named Okouchi have an odd friendship/relationship as Okouchi is naturally athletic and beautiful and wishes she could ‘just disappear’; she wishes she could be like Shiroyama, while Shiroyama wants to be like Okouchi – oh those high school days, never loving ourselves much). We see Shiroyama try to hide the pain as teachers brutally exclude her because of her disability (“What if you became translucent? We can’t take the chance”) while it is up to her and her friends to find the solutions to convince others that yes, this can and will work (reminds me of when I was trying to get permission to do wheelchair boxing).

Shiroyama meets Keiko, an older woman who has advanced stages of the syndrome, who tells her not to delude herself, that she must learn to be independent because if she has a partner, she won’t be able to support them as much as she needs support (Keiko’s ex-boyfriend feels differently and is constantly trying to convince Keiko otherwise). This gives Shiroyama the ‘disability guilts.’ She doesn’t want to be the person who makes her boy friend Tadami stop smiling. She thinks she will suck out his joy because he worries so much about her, or he will have to look out for her, or is stuck with her (see panel below – click to enlarge).
Shiroyama, because of her condition is plagued with doubts and the more she puts herself out there, the more hurt she risks. She loves acting and wants to be an actress. But then, though chosen as the lead of the school play, she wonders if she should pull out, because what if she becomes translucent and ruins it for everyone (I’ve had this feeling in many different variations). Her friend Okouchi gives her a bit of a slap and tells her to smarten up, because, yes, she is going to have to take chances and yes, people will hurt her but she either lives in fear the rest of her life or not. (see panel below –click to enlarge).
The second book has Tadami and Shiroyama go on a date and includes some kids staring at Shiroyama’s disability and start making comments. Tadami steps in and turns things around, showing how he views her and how isn’t the syndrome cool! But secretly he has been reading everything he can and as defacto caregiver is becoming worried and obsessed not only about his own helplessness at times but not knowing enough to make sure he can help Shiroyama (strike any chords with caregivers out there?). He ends up having a long talk with Keiko’s on and off again boyfriend, who explains to him why he is there for Keiko and why he knows she is the one for him. Meanwhile Shiroyama is going to acting auditions and getting turned down. She doesn’t know if it is because they only see her disability or because she just isn’t a good enough actress (again, this resonates with me; in job interviews, in social situations – is it me, or is it my disability?). The books regularly include the way that medical treatment, examinations and the entire medical system which has become part of Shiroyama’s life. In book two it includes an incident of physician discrimination: where he either doesn’t believe her, isn’t comfortable treating her and/or includes the other types of discrimination females with disabilities can receive at the hands of doctors. It is the inclusion of incidents like this, the REAL LIFE aspect of it which make me recommend this series so highly.

One of the purposes of literature is so that we can see our own lives and ourselves reflected and there just isn’t a lot of disability related fiction literature out there. So whether you are a teen or an adult with a disability; whether a teen or an adult who is a friend, a partner, a boyfriend, a girlfriend or someone significant in the life of a person with a disability, I recommend you buy and share this series of books. What other books reflect the lives of both the person with disability AND the caregiver/partner/friend; what other books can be read by both people and discussed so the person on each side learns a little more about what it is to be the person on the OTHER side. I learned more in reading and talking about these books with Linda about why she WANTS to be with me, than I ever learned in trying to analyze her motives my head (which was filled with my own insecurities). The books spoke for her, articulating what she felt, but could not make me understand. It even reflects and makes me understand why Linda gets so bossy (because she is worried) reflected when Tadami does the same as he feels that Shiroyama isn’t taking enough care of herself, isn’t understanding how serious medical complications from her condition could become.

Don’t worry, I haven’t ruined the plot but only scratched the surface of some of the many reasons you should pick up this series. Linda, who finds manga hard if not impossible to read (because of the drawing style) found these books easy to read and follow and enjoyed them a lot. Each book is about 200 pages and Book 3 is coming out Jan 23rd (you know I have a copy on order). Seriously, for those partners, for those friends, for those lovers, for those with disabilities; don’t you want to read a series of books where YOU are the hero?

13 comments:

Sober @ Sundown said...

Hi Beth,

Thanks for stopping by my blog. It is good to hear from you again.

Happy New Year!

lilwatchergirl said...

Sounds awesome :) I'll have a look for it. The under-representation of disabled people in media of all sorts is something I'm interested in researching (but which will, of course, end up by the wayside, because there's so much else I want to research - even though it would probably be more interesting than researching medical discrimination towards disabled people, or things along those 'very serious' lines). But it's always good to come across representations of Us. And the best ones all seem to come under that very wide 'fantasy' umbrella. My favourite current example being 'Heroes'. This is useful, as my biggest literary interest in fantasy. Ah... I'll become a researcher yet.

Katrin said...

WOW! And less than $10?!

saraarts said...

"Translucent syndrome"? Brilliant. Just brilliant.

Gaina said...

If she's translucent, and sometimes transparent, she can wall through walls and climb stairs right? Heck, I'll take translucency over Spina Bifida any day! LOL

Seriously though, I can see how it would be a good way to teach children about disability, despite the fact it seems heavy on the metaphors from what you're saying here (and obviously you'd have to edit out the 'adult' bits! haha). Me? I like 'straight-up and in your face' reality. I wonder if there's a danger that the message won't stay with the average reader, for them to apply to real life because the translucency seems more like a superpower than a disability, and the character is a drawing and therefore removed from real people.

Have you read 'Under the Eye of the Clock' by Christopher Nolan? It's fabulous, and really confronts the reader with the reality of day-to-day disability.

I'm just having a look on Amazon now at books tackling disability and I'm a bit disappointed (but not surprised) by how many of them have no reviews - and I'm assuming this is because no-one read them.

I think Versace and the like should start making wheelchairs and convince all the ‘Twit Girls’ they are this years must-have accessory (making easier to carry your new exotic pet or pointless little rat-dog). THEN you’d see people become more interested in disability! It’s appealing to the lowest common denominator, I know but it’ll have the desired effect.

Anonymous said...

I'm going to get this as a gift for someone who loves manga and the history of medicine, if not a copy for me to reward myself when I finish a project I'm working on.

I feel the same way sometimes with caregiver issues, keep asking my husband why he loves me/stays with me, but he says he absolutely wouldn't leave. The thought doesn't cross his mind.

Anonymous said...

Oh, and the only other representation where I've felt some kinship is the film of Frida Kahlo's life.

Elizabeth McClung said...

Hey sober, good to hear from you too.

Lilwatchergirl - I am sure it is available on Amazon.co.uk as well - and you are right, that these is so much underrepresentation in media but even more when it is something like this: life and the world from OUR view and the view of people who care about us. (Though I heard they are turning the diving bell and the butterfly into a film).

Katrin: Yeah, getting the first book used including shipping is like $6.

Sara: I would really be interested in hearing what you think....after you read it (hint, hint - Linda did say one part seemed rather optimistic)

Anon: I find it odd that they are marketing it as "a shojo romance with a TWIST" instead of a romance and a look at life with a disability (because I guess the those with disablities aren't enough of a market force? Hey 1 in 7 right?).

Elizabeth McClung said...

Giana: Sorry my computer posted yours late - actually what is good is the way they keep the metaphor going so no, she doesn't walk through walls but rather, if she in injuried (at a part where she is translucent) no one can notice. And she has to come up with adaptive devices of her own.

I do have the Chris Nolan book, I had forgotten that - as for classification I was finding that even books where the main characters had disabilities like Stoner and Spaz didn't show up under books regarding disabilities.

Anon: Yeah, the Frida film was a "lesbian" film for me but now it is a "disability" film - I guess that is how perspective changes.

cheryl g. said...

You know I've always thought of Frida as a disability movie with a lesbian flair. Looks like I'm placing an order with Amazon.

Liz said...

This sound great. I'm buying it and I'll blog about it when I read it! Thanks for the tip and for the detailed review.

- Liz
http://badgerbag.typepad.com

Marla said...

This is interesting because I saw a book at the book store that was about autism with the same art work and story style.

Elizabeth McClung said...

Cheryl: okay, but actually, I just rent mine or better yet, order a hold on it from the library for free online (Do they have this service where you are?)

Liz: sounds, good, I am very interesting in comparing your view of it to ours. Or really anyone's view of it to mine since it seems to be have slipped under the PWD radar.

Marla: I would be interested in this book if it was a manga - definately, so please let me know if you find the name; I did see a video documentary on Austism Spectrum Disorder called Normal People Scare Me.