Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Doris Lessing and blogging: time waster or enternal tale?

This is a little blurb because, through Kate in Wales, I found that Doris Lessing has poo-pooed the blog, and bloggers in a piece in the Guardian (known to lovers of spelling as the Gaurdain due to the profuse spelling errors it contains) saying: “the internet has seduced a whole generation with its inanities so that even quite reasonable people will confess that once they are hooked it is hard to cut free and they may find a whole day has passed in blogging."

My first reaction is that anything Doris Lessing is against is probably something I should try. It is like being told not to date someone with a motorcycle by your grandmother. My second and more thoughtful reaction is: That old hypocrite.

Blogs and blogging have brought the literary and the inane; the wacky daily photo-shopped picture to the political pundit. But the one group it has freed to equal or greater status is women. Women write blogs and women read blogs. While guys are off playing on-line games in the hundreds of millions (something else Doris Lessing probably hates….so enjoy!), women are blogging about baking, about crafts, about mothering, about life. There has never before in history been the expanse of female experience to see, to participate in, to understand and be part of as today. And I believe that is far more to do with blogging than the existence of Doris Lessing and Joyce Carol Oates (no offense to the works of either).

One of the central purposes of literature is to ask the basic human questions: Why? Does what I do matter? What does this mean? And most important, am I alone? Most of us, before this computer generation, found that spark of connection between two minds and spirits through a book. And still, I am connected to women (and men) long dead through books.

The reason I write a blog instead of writing a novel (although I actually do both) is because at this stage of my life, I am driven both by the need to narrate MY story, whatever its end, and the need to know I am not alone in doing this. I need a community and as a mostly housebound individual, blogs and blogging give me that community in a depth and breadth I could not achieve in any other current form.

The reason I read blogs is the same reason I read books, only more so; to understand or at least get a glimpse of what life is like for point X, for person X, for the life from 'here'. If someone came to me and said, “How do I learn about children in the autistic spectrum” I would NOT give them the book The curious incident of the Dog in the Night (since I think it is holding up the end of my couch). I would point them to Crystal Jigsaw and Marla and Casdok at Mother of Shrek and the many, many other excellent blog sites written by people within the autistic spectrum and those who care and love them. No novel can replace the nitty gritty experience from the individuals perspective. And that is what we have here, individual perspectives, some wonderful and eloquent, some rough and in-your-face and what you take from it and what you learn is up to you. You want entertainment? There are thousands of blog writers waiting to do it; want to be challenged on your political beliefs, religious beliefs, cheese eating beliefs? There are hundreds to thousands waiting to do that as well. As a reader, when have you ever had the joyful abundance as now? And for free? With a blog you can share a hobby with someone halfway around the world and encourage each other on. The comments left by people I have never met have helped me get through a day. The writing of someone who has never been 'officially' published has MANY TIMES helped me see my life in a different way.

And this is bad, how?

I write because first I am a writer and while I am not too sure on the plot, what I have going on in my life is GREAT material (would be nice to know where the climax might occur though). But second because, unlike women of a few generations ago, I will not go out of here leaving only a journal in a drawer, or some collections of writings which might be published after my death. My history will stand to be sifted in the here and now.

When I lie in bed at night, and the fear creeps in, I know that I am NOT alone. I know that other people, other women who may not have exactly my condition have felt this, have struggled with the uncertainty, the pain, the isolation, the medical system, the whole chorus of whispers in the darkness. I know this because they wrote it down and I read it. And so I will write it down and someone else will read it. And the writing will be fun, and it will be silly and serious and sad and all the other things that make us human. And when my turn comes, and my blog falls silent, then the story, this particular thread of the human story will be taken up by another voice. And it needs no editor, no board of approval, no publishing costs. Just the time and determination to continue.

This is “a seduction” I embrace.

16 comments:

em said...

Thank you. That was beautiful.

Elizabeth said...

This post *so* hits the nail on the proverbial head.

Communal storytelling does happen to predate Formal Writing, now doesn't it? I see snobbish comments like Lessing's as little more than foot stampy fits by people who are *used* to having a gatekeeper role in media. Hello, sorry you don't have *all* the marbles to yourself anymore.

(Oh, and, FWIW, my oldest son is autistic and I'm passionate about "Curious Incident". I do give that book out to folks looking for insight into the autistic mind...tho, if I ever needed something under my couch leg, I've probably got a few extra copies here.)

thanks, E

lilwatchergirl said...

Oh, I am in SUCH agreement. Blogging is good for writing. It's good for community. It's good for lives. It's a new art form, and one day people will marvel at it in the same way that they marvel at the early novels for establishing an artistic genre that has lasted for centuries and changed the thinking of many people.

Happy Blogging, Elizabeth.

KateJ said...

Thanks for the promo! It wasn't actually a piece by Doris Lessing in the "Grauniad" (as we all know and love it) but a quote from her Nobel prize acceptance speech. Apparently she has since said on BBC radio (according to our mutual friend KathZ) that she didn't mean blogs as such but social networking. Well,I think the same thing applies. A teenage friend of my son is currently unable to speak, following a jaw op. He is keeping in touch with all his friends via MySpace, FaceBook and whatever. Pretty important for him, and for all those people for whom the 'net is their only way of reaching the "real" world.

KateJ said...

...and yes, I'm with you on everything you say. Women blog. Old people blog (yes, even people older than Doris). Disabled, disempowered and otherwise silenced and invisible people blog.
If it was just Doris Lessing it wouldn't matter so much, but it seems to be the view of many other "professional" writers and journalists. People like us blog when we have something to say, while many of these people have to fill their page quota so fill it with piffle... after all, they're getting paid for it.

Disabled Giant said...

You're post rings so true to a lot of things my wife and I have talked about. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

saraarts said...

Nicely put.

I have never paid any attention to Doris Lessing except when forced to read in school one or more of her short stories that I can't even remember, so I'm afraid I have no idea how much I'm supposed to value her opinion about anything at all. Since she doesn't know or love me, I'm going to pass on worrying about it.

I do find it sort of amusing whenever one of the pillars of The Establishment gets his/her/its undies in a knot about the Rise of the Amateur. Oh, my, how threatening! People deciding for themselves what they want to write and read and talk about, what they want to do with their own minds and disposable resources. Goodness. Don't they know how much quality they are forcing the The Culture to sacrifice?

Bah.

Marla said...

Eliz-This is a beautiful, beautiful post. I do feel fortunate to have "met" friends through blogging. It is indeed a different sort of friendship. I wish I would have known about blogging years ago when I was struggling even more to help Maizie. I bet I would have looked at things in a better light earlier on. I am sure I would have felt support that I did not feel from family and friends back then. I also need to feel like I am able to accomplish at least something on a daily basis. Blogging gives me that. Thank you for mentioning my blog in your post. That is high praise, indeed.

Tui said...

Amen! :)

What does Miss Lessing know about these internets, anyway? She is completely missing the point. I know people who watch hours and hours of TV, and live vicariously through reality shows, and yet, these same people, look down their noses at time spent on the internet, even though it is truly interactive.

JaneB said...

I concur.

In my part of Britain the Guardian is called the 'Grauniad' - less of a tounge-twister?

Gaina said...

**stands up, applaudes....and falls flat on her face** :D

I agree with you 100%. I have learned so much about other cultures etc, from blogs and I do think it's more effective when you can learn it 'from the horses mouth' if you like.

I often wonder if people who criticise things like blogging are secretly jealous because they don't have the talent or the courage to do it themselves.

cheryl g. said...

Hear, hear! Well said! Blogging is about connections with and insights into other people, cultures and experiences. A beautiful post. I am grateful to you and all the other bloggers I read for sharing your lives.

Elizabeth McClung said...

em: Thanks for the compliment, it touches me.

Elizabeth: the communial story telling, exactly, what is different between us and the bards or stories around the campfire during the winter? Have you read Elizabeth Moon's Book inspired by her autistic child, it is very very good. It is call Speed of Dark.

lilwatchergirl: Yes, getting people to write every day or many times a week, how is that not better for literature as a whole? When the movies came in everyone said theatre was dead; when TV came in everyone said Movies were dead - stories and the human experience always lives on in as many forms as possible.

KateJ: yes, the Grauniad, I knew it was some jumble and couldn't remember the exact one so I made a guess. I remember thinking the first day "I've got to call the editor, if a dyslexic like me is finding spelling errors...." Then I read the next day's paper, and the next and eventually just shrugged.

Thanks for the amplification, but I agree, how is communication to more people a bad thing? I think it is great that so many people spend so much time with the written word AND don't get paid for it - says something about our "going downhill and becoming illiterate society" doesn't it?

Disabled Giant: thanks for commenting, I saw on your blog that you are even taller than I - we need to start a "People with Disabilities who are TALL too" Group.

Sara: I admit if it had been someone I truely respected and revered I would have been a bit more heart broken but Doris Lessing was never a favorite of mine and I never understood how she became "a literary woman of merit" over others from the same period. Yes, oh hand wringing - Culture with a capital C is degraded if just ANYONE could do it.

Marla: it is so true, and Linda says that I am more content on a day when I blog because I might be having a pain day, a bad day a whatever day but at least I did SOMETHING.

Tui: Such a good point, why is it whatever we do is bad: TV is bad because we are passive, games are bad because we are not passive but we aren't learning the right things, now blogging is bad because I guess there is just so much of it and if there is that much well - oh no! I have a friend who adopted a child from China and blogs about raising the child and reads the blogs of those who have adopted a child from china. I never would have imagined that kind of support and cross information 10 years ago. But here it is!

Janeb: You are correct, being an ex-brit now and unable to find someone to verify, I had to take my best bet (not that Cardiff was the home of a lot of Guardian readers - I had to look a bit high and low some weekends to find one). Thanks for commenting.

Gaina: You know I will never turn down a physical slapstick joke - haha. I remember during the gulf war there was the blogger who blogged from Bagdad and I think about 1/2 the world read his blog to get "the other side of the story" - just that freedom, to find someone sitting in an event telling what they see and how it effects them without editors or military censors - it is so amazing.

Cheryl g: The one thing that blogging has taught me is how many people I DO have a connection with and yet how individual every single person is - it is the human experience in a hundred thousand voices and I don't know why anyone would want to silence it?

Lisa Harney said...

It's always disappointing when someone wants to dismiss the blogosphere (or online socializing in general) because it's so painfully clear that they don't get it, and because the part of my social life that's online is devalued because it happens over a computer.

People online do it all the time, with comments about how stuff online just isn't important enough to engage and should be ignored.

Thank you for writing this.

soubriquet said...

I just read your post....
I wonder how many of the people who made derogatory comments about Doris Lessing have read anything by her?
Or know anything about her?
I'm definitely against her alleged comments on bloggers, but to call Lessing a pillar of the establishment is to do her a cruel disservice.
She has been a thorn in the side of several establishments, and on being told she had won the Nobel prize for literature she was exasperated, getting her shopping out of the car, struggling through an obstructing clamour of journalists, she was being a curmudgeonly old woman, 88 years of life, and "what the hell is so great about being awarded yet another prize?"
My recommendation, to anybody who wants to see beyond the grauniad's soundbite, is to read her Nobel speech at http://preview.tinyurl.com/38gcfn
Here, however is the relevant passage:
"We are in a fragmenting culture, where our certainties of even a few decades ago are questioned and where it is common for young men and women who have had years of education, to know nothing about the world, to have read nothing, knowing only some speciality or other, for instance, computers.
What has happened to us is an amazing invention, computers and the internet and TV, a revolution. This is not the first revolution we, the human race, has dealt with. The printing revolution, which did not take place in a matter of a few decades, but took much longer, changed our minds and ways of thinking. A foolhardy lot, we accepted it all, as we always do, never asked "What is going to happen to us now, with this invention of print?" And just as we never once stopped to ask, How are we, our minds, going to change with the new internet, which has seduced a whole generation into its inanities so that even quite reasonable people will confess that once they are hooked, it is hard to cut free, and they may find a whole day has passed in blogging and blugging etc.
Very recently, anyone even mildly educated would respect learning, education, and owe respect to our great store of literature. Of course we all know that when this happy state was with us, people would pretend to read, would pretend respect for learning, but it is on record that working men and women longed for books, and this is evidenced by the working men's libraries, institutes, colleges of the 18th and 19th centuries.
Reading, books, used to be part of a general education."

Her comments were not snobbish, rather she was seeking to question a whole new media, wondering where it will take us.

I've read a few of her books.
I doubt she's ever read any of my blog-words. I don't think I'll lose any sleep over it.
I wonder who'll get the first Nobel prize for blogging? Not me, I bet.

Keep on blogging.

High Heels said...

I think Doris Lessing is great. But in this case, I think she's misguided and/or misinformed. Keep blogging.