I have heard it in a dozen different ways but it all boils down to “What did you do?”, “Why are you sick?”, “When are you going to get better?” and most important “What are going to do about ‘it’?” (It being the aspect of being ill that, if I could figure out, would somehow be in my control).
There is this slippery line between illness and disability; which also seems to occur between personal responsibility and adapting. No matter what people say, no one, including me, can accept that things “just happen.” Most of our religion, our society, our interactions and the way we can tell good people from bad people is based on what happens to people, how they act and how much they are AT FAULT.
So what did happen to me? I get asked it almost every time I leave the house. To ask, “What happened?” means that something did happen, that something perhaps is still happening. You can’t say, “I got the flu” without three people telling you a) you should have gotten a flu shot, b) they never get sick and c) most people don’t wash their hands as much as they should. A few days ago I asked a home care worker about her union and pointed out that she should be covered for a disability pension. She replied, “I don’t care about that, why would I?” Then realizing that she was the same age as me said, “Well, I’m sure you didn’t care about it before.”
No, I didn’t. I thought I had 30-35 years of teaching university and doing research. Ten years to pay off any debts and save enough for a condo then a nice life of travel and saving. I spent my life “investing in my future” as we are told only the wisest of us will do; I spent my time and money investing in getting credentials and training that no one currently cares about. They don’t care because it is in THIS body, and while Stephen Hawking may have a university research position, I don’t know exactly how he made the short list to the interview (I can’t with the ones I apply to); he certainly didn’t have a good CV/Resume.
And how am I “fighting” for my health? We in the west think that with enough money and philosophies to rip off, there is an instant answer to everything. That cancer responds to negative thoughts; that if I’m not centered or have a list or a plan then I’m not “fighting.” What’s to fight? As egocentric as I am/was, I never thought my heart beat because I ordered it; and now that the part of my brain that gives it orders seems to be shorting out, what am I supposed to do? Yell at it?
I am coming up on my 11th straight month of deterioration. And I have a sort of stability; or rather the ordinary is creeping back in to steal time away; dental problems, computer problems, family stuff. And while it leaves me limp like seaweed after high tide, since no one sees me, what does it matter?
How can I be insulted much by people who question if there is something I have done or some reason I am sick when I question it myself? I’m not disabled as much as broken or breaking. And I’m sure that if anyone deserves what is happening to me, it IS me. I certainly never treated my body the respect it deserved; I was anorexic, self harming, and generally used my body like a disposable toy. Well, when I labor to expand my lungs, or listen as my heart struggles erratically on; it certainly has a lot more of my attention now. I’m not a saint; I don’t think I’ve done anything particularly horrid, I try to live by a set of rules that respect all humans and their right to make personal decisions. But then again, this condition isn’t something I would want anyone else to have to experience. So I guess if I had to choose between me and someone else, it might as well be me.
My home care professionals, health professionals, doctors and people in health care tell me, when they are scared, that they don’t see conditions like this, not all in one person, sometimes not at all; it is just something they’ve read about in a book. Things that might happen someplace far away, like children starving in Africa.
Do I think I have offended God? Well, the thought crossed my mind but the real reason I stay away from Christians is that I honestly think God likes me; that I’m sort of a favorite. I mean, if the bible is your anecdotal evidence, painful, unexplainable conditions, which slowly waste away a person’s strength, dignity and hope are how you tell God has taken a personal interest in you.
No matter how much I do, or how much it hurts, I think (those times I am not hallucinating in pain) that I should have done more; that I need to do more. It’s odd being backlogged with your own illness. If I could just get a remission, a stabilizing, then maybe I could make sense of something, anything. I know that even this mental state, after days and days of extreme pain and fatigue is something others have gone through. I wonder where they are? Aren’t they supposed to be here selling me a book on the 10 things I have to repeat to myself in the mirror to cure myself?
I don’t know what to do now. I’d like to be able to go outside again. I’d like to be strong enough to shower again. I’d like to know what I am supposed to be doing or thinking? What I do think about is having margarita’s with friends; talking, laughing, not worrying about my oxygen levels or my core temp. Hell, I’d like to have friends who would go out to margarita’s with me, since I can’t get any of the home care workers to commit.
There is some sort of belief between the cracks that I should have a life that is MEANINGFUL. That I still have choices, and I know very well that soon, maybe within months or a year or two I will have almost no choices at all. So what choices do I make; what narrow path out there will give me peace or joy or some sort of emotional or physical solution?
Last night, pulled to the floor, on oxygen, I couldn’t expand one of my lungs. To describe the pain, all I can say is that I would have willingly….eagerly cut into the spaces between my ribs with a scalpel if I thought I could have, not ended, but just eased that pain. But I couldn’t cut anything because I couldn’t move; barely conscious, paralyzed, with part of one hand to make tapping and signs. Later, when I was conscious and had control over one hand and arm, I wrote for the carer: ‘The pain?’ She nodded that she understood what pain I was talking about. ‘My future?’ Was this going to be my life in six months, or nine or eighteen? She didn’t know but she didn’t think so.
It isn’t just a question of suicide or thinking morbidly or the worst. You simply can’t experience pain like that and not NEED to know if that is what you are going to be facing more and more often.
Of course there is the post dissection. Did I try to move too much that day? The previous day? Did I stay up too late? Did I not go on oxygen soon enough? Did I talk too much? How, the question begs, did I bring this upon myself?
Certain illnesses don’t make very good storytelling. There is no build-up to a climax, there is no resolution, indeed, it is hard to tell when and where in the plot you are at all or even who the good people and the bad people are. Is it a horror story or a fairy tale? An adventure story? What is the theme? I think in the US and Canada the theme is “Don’t get sick.” I’m just not sure how I go about doing that, right here, right now. Some weird spammer guy keeps sending me long rants which start with “You may have been evil/preditory in your last life and this disability is how they are punishing you.” Well, at least now I know right? (hooray for comment moderation!)
1 hour ago



29 comments:
I've been getting those rants in comments too. Pretty long rants that seem to go on and on from that guy.
I really dislike the 'tude you talk about where people try to place blame on the person who is ill/disabled as if he/she could have avoided the mishap/illness/whatever by doing a, b or c. How sad to have to deal with that as well as all the other health issues you're facing...
Ruth: thanks for the comment; that guy sure can write and write (with no spell check!). I think the attitude is either one which comes with flu season or one I am spending more time asking myself.
I think wanting to have some idea of what the next six months is going to be like, pain, mobility and options wise is a normal thing. I wish I had answers but I am not going to be ashamed of being ashamed of asking questions. How can I not, on some night, lying in the darkness, not wonder if I deserve this? Isn't that normal?
Not only asking why, but in the absence of an answer making up the answer is a fairly normal part of the process. Guilt tends to accompany grief.
However, as you've alluded to, there are two ways you can go on this stuff. I tend to think about these things in terms of Catholicism and Protestantism on account of the two halves of my family; the Protestant half tended to believe that bad things don't happen to good people and the Catholics tended to believe that bad things only happen to good people.
One chronically ill Catholic family friend speaks of offering up her suffering in order to save her time in purgatory, and also to get time off for the folks she prays for. Every bit of pain can be used as a cosmic bargaining chip.
I can't buy it myself, but it is very useful to realise that different folks have applied quite different meaning to the same experience.
Will you find your own? I don't know. It's a unique experience which only you are allowed to apply meaning to.
And wanting to know the future... All I can suggest is, quite seriously, make plans. You can't make rock solid plans; I really hope this does have some let up.
But planning in the sense of if A happens, then I want B, and especially talking it through with the people most important to you, can take some of the terror away.
It's heartbreaking reading what you're going through. And to receive comments like you mentioned, it makes me lose faith in humanity.
Although my symptoms don't sound nearly as bad (or as painful) as yours, I can empathize with the thought process. I'm used to running 15+ hours a day in productive mode, and since this started, I average 5 good hours before I'm mentally and physically exhausted. Everyone here's been mostly supportive, but I'm starting to see a bit of frustration from some students that I'm not on top of things like I should be (at least in their eyes -- they don't say anything to my face). And then the most common cause cited for my mystery illness? "Well, you know you work too hard, and really this is just a sign you need to slow down." So, it's my fault for being productive/motivated or something. I hate that. I almost wish they'd just tell me it was SOMETHING because the not knowing seems worse in some ways. Anyway, sorry for the ramble.
OMG, I've been getting those rants, too! Yesterday I got one in response to my "Totally, Totally Cheating" post -- which post happened to be about cheating on NaBlo, fer chrissakes -- which told me "this kind of behavior" would be punished by me living in a disaster zone.
Wow! If only life were that logical! Cheat on NaBlo = have your mobile home ripped up by a tornado! Sure, makes perfect sense!
We so want there to be reasons for the rotten things that happen, even if it makes us look personally deficient or wrong. It's easier if we think there is something we did to cause what happened to us or that we could have done something to prevent it. It makes us feel more powerful than if we are just poor little random organisms to which terrible things happen for no personal reason.
As for the endless questions, my favorite is always, "But you're okay now, aren't you?" I suspect wheelchair users are less prone to this than amputees because most ABs think that only accidents or horrible, wasting illnesses can land you in a wheelchair permanently, and the fact of being in a wheelchair is perceived as its own answer to the question, viz., no, you're obviously not okay if you're still sitting down. It's ignorant, but it's the conclusion I think most people automatically draw.
By contrast, amputation is generally understood, through the miracle of television, to be either a trauma in and of itself or a horrifying but bold, life-saving measure which makes everything magically okay. Lots of us, though, have just agreed to go through with it in order to dramatically lessen immediate, otherwise insoluble misery and slow down the dying. Since this does not occur to most people, especially if the person they're looking at doesn't otherwise appear "sick," it's kind of freaky for them to understand for the first time that someone would choose this without being guaranteed anything at all, especially while that someone is looking them in the eye telling them so.
There are so many foregone conclusions about us based strictly on our apparent physical health floating around in the heads around us. It's daunting when you realize you now have to swim through all that for the rest of your life, as well as everything else that has changed.
I can so relate to this about my son.
Goldfish: Well, thanks for the two perspectives, since my christianity was neither protestant nor Catholic but more Amish cult I don't exactly think I have bargaining chips. I guess I am concerned somewhat that I will come across as a nutjob who has found "a rainbow of light in suffering" or some other bizaare statement - When really, all I want is SOME kind of normal, even a new broken down normal that I can depend on.
Tornwordo: Well, I think a lot of people are scared and in pain for a lot of different reasons, and if making me the bad person makes their life make sense, maybe that seems like a safe idea to them. As for me, I'm too exhausted to do anything but confess - what's that? Did I write the gay agenda? Yes, totally! And I am ready to name the other witches in my village? And I believe all kinds of heresy, just burn me and get it over with!
artistic soul: I am glad you shared how you are feeling and thinking. I know for us super-A type people, when used to depending on OURSELVES and now that is gone, and there seems no reason, how hard it is to explain over and over about mysterious illness which shake up everything including self confidence.
Sara: Wait, aren't you supposed to be the cheerful one who has an answer for me that will solve everything. And now I find that reality is confusing and is likely to stay that way?
I still get "Are you having a good day?" questions in a tone that implies that if I WANTED to have a good day, I could, but deep down I must love being in pain (or rather that if I had better breeding, I at least wouldn't ooze my suffering over other people like a commoner!)
Casdok: Yeah, the voices inside our head are so fun aren't they?
I think the basic human condition of consciusness consists almost entirely of trying to figure out what went wrong.
I think there was a time in human history when people simply didn't think for themselves, probably before 2,000 BC or so.
People simply relied on right brain "inner voices", or the voices of unquestioned authority figures who "heard from the gods".
We haven't been actually employing critical thinking for all that long, so naturally most of us aren't very good at it.
Oh, I knew one woman with congenital heart problems who made the rounds of all the faith healers until they started telling her that her problem must be due to some secret sin.
Of course they were doing this to cover for their own inability to work the magic they thought was prescribed by the Bible, but their blame shifting was damaging to her, nonetheless. nonetheless.
I wonder how the evil spammer guy will be punished for his comments in his next life. (I hope he's reading this as it might set him thinking ...)
I can't think of any helpful/useful comments so am just pausing to send best wishes.
Sheesh, who is this mad ranter? Just what you need, a guilt trip. What makes these people so certain that they "have it all figured out"? How obnoxious!
I once lived on a tiny island with a year round population of 7 (sometimes 9) and, believe it or not, Jehovah's Witnesses would still make it out in their boats to come save our heathen souls.
Anyway, on a completely different subject, I tagged you over at my blog...
"Wait, aren't you supposed to be the cheerful one who has an answer for me that will solve everything. And now I find that reality is confusing and is likely to stay that way?"
Oh, no, I'm failing again!!! Crap!
The problem is that I have utterly lost all faith in any kind of god strictly because of the amount of random suffering in the world. However, I've decided that it doesn't matter to me whether I deserve whatever good and bad things happen to me, only that I make the most of the good and try to share it as much as possible.
And I know I'm not the only one here who appreciates the good stuff you are still sharing with us, including pieces like this. Authenticity, an honest record of our real experience, is one of the most valuable things we have to offer each other as humans in this world.
See? The nauseating pollyanna is still there. She's just an atheist.
I so relate to those questions. Everything you wrote made me think, oh yes, it is reasonable to question this stuff. Because I do it myself, see? But the thing is that I'm starting to believe it is a problem that I do that. Sort of a liability of a gigantic brain, because where is there ever peace from wondering that stuff, from hoping to find the way where it all makes sense and can be fixed? Me, I'm desperate to fix everything.
Oh and the guy ranting about your karma has karma of his own to clean up. In fact, he's making more now.
Daniel: the split consciousness of the bicamerial mind? Any messages from God I am keeping to myself. Yes, at the end of the day the best "cover your ass" move is to blame the sick person.
Kathz: Thanks for your best wishes, I am not patient - I want the spammer to have a computer virus in THIS life.
Mental Mosiac: thanks for the tag; yes, if only we at Pride Parade had the dedication to bring pride day to an island of 9 people. Sigh.
Sara: Linda really agrees with your second paragraph because when I first became disabled I tried to find something similar.
Don't worry, almost everyone Christian considers me an atheist (God is an agnostic concerning my existence). I'm glad to hear you're optimism is back. Now, please send me the quick fix!
Em: I think it's reasonable to question these things. Linda, however, feels I should I do less of it at 2am and maybe turn over and go to sleep. I can see her point except... she never answers my questions FULLY. So that's two sides.
Thanks for the comments everyone.
I choose to thing that ranters like the guy you described are so miserable and twisted that they project that on others around them... having said that, I also think their hatefulness and ignorance should cause them excruciating pain at the least.
To quote a great line from a TV show... "If God handed out diseases as punishment for our sins we'd all spend every moment down at the free clinic."
Cool bandaids and mug!
Yikes. I think I will turn my comment moderation back on. I wish I could take all your pain away. Chronic pain is hell. There are no good reasons for any of it. I bet there are some people out there reading your blog who don't comment and are in pain and see the love and light in your posts, the honesty you bring through in your writing is rare. You have a gift. Keep writing and sharing. I am sure that is easier said than done when every day is such a struggle. I love that despite your pain and struggles you continue to try and are so determined. Think of all the people that have their health and do so little. You are a good person. Don't let anyone make you think anything but.
I deleted at least one from that guy recently too, or some other long-winded and ranty guy who was full of moral recriminations for, um, something I may have done, that was done unto me recently. I lost interest after the second sentence or so.
I left the one up from the guy who said he was the messiah, though. It was quite a while ago, and the post he'd commented on was old then, IIRC. He'd linked to a website he'd set up to sell copies of his self-published books, which I generally delete posts of a commercial nature, even from the messiah, but he'd included a link to a free .pdf file of the whole book, so he wasn't just trying to make a buck. Also, I mean, how often does the messiah stop by just to chat?
But more seriously, I dunno what it all means, all those questions and the answers people have for them. Only that it doesn't make sense, and I can't make it make sense. And neither can they.
I agree with Sara, pretty much.
When I'm in my more charitable moods, I try really hard to remember that other folks are telling me their crazyass ideas [about illness being caused by something I or they or whomever we're talking about did or failed to do] in an effort to be helpful when they feel (and in fact are) helpless. It's also part of the impulse to force the world to make sense, even if it's uglier than random wacked-out old reality. Nothing like a good conspiracy theory: blame exists, it must be assigned to someone, or ... I dunno what happens.
Does this help me sleep nights or be less annoyed/offended whenever it happens?
Alas, no.
Positive attitudes don't slow or cure cancer. I know you know that, but there's an actual study saying that there's no reason to blame the patient.
The Interrogation, the attempts to make you justify why you let this happen, why this is your life, and the assumption that you can somehow make it stop if only you try hard enough? People who say that stuff to you are ignorant.
The personal examination is natural. We try hard to explain to ourselves why things happen, try to find a cause or meaning, whether there's one to find or not.
The difference here is boundaries. It's fine to interrogate yourself, to try to dig stuff out and learn something, because you already have to live with being you. When someone walks up to you and demands you justify how you can be sick, and implies that it's somehow your fault for not fighting hard enough, or having a negative attitude, or just plain living your life wrong (whatever the hell that means), they're making your life about them and imposing their assumptions on you. For whatever reason, they're trying their issues your responsibility.
At least, that's why I get offended when someone does the Interrogation to me when they realize I'm trans.
Wanting a normalcy to depend on is perfectly normal. Nothing you're doing or saying about this stuff is unusual.
There is this slippery line between illness and disability; which also seems to occur between personal responsibility and adapting. No matter what people say, no one, including me, can accept that things “just happen.”
This has been interesting me recently, too. Why do people quiz us so unwaveringly about what we've been "doing" about our situations? I have a relative who responds to *every* comment I make about illness/disability - even a mention that I can't do something because the place where it's held isn't accessible - with something like "If you just thought more positively, you'd feel much better." Not even finding out that my condition is regarded among specialists to be genetic, life-long and incurable is discouraging her from such comments. It's highly irritating, and rather Victorian. But I seem to be unable to defend myself against it...
And that spammer bloke is hitting everyone I know. He's seriously irritating. Comment moderation is a gift from the gods. Or Blogger.
Cheryl G: well, it certainly isn't what you want to see in the morning so yeah, I think if this guy got like hemmeroids (sic) I wouldn't be sobbing myself to sleep.
Marla: Thanks very much for the encouragement in life and to keep writing. Often I feel very dissatified with my writing, that it is not "up to par" - but then I am sure I don't have a "perfectionist" type personality. I think most people do so many amazing things; I never knew how much I did in a day till I couldn't do it anymore. Thankfully I just have to figure out living for me; you have a child to live for too.
Alphabitch: darn, great name, can I be a BetaBitch, or DeltaBitch (I don't know if I have what it takes to be an alpha). True, you don't get a lot of personal comments from a messiah - I might read twice. As for the questions; I think this is sort of Elizabeth on Elizabeth - my embedded AB Elizabeth is just another voice questioning the present Elizabeth of "Come on, you really can't figure out SOMETHING to do to get better?" I always believed life was a paradox, I just didn't expect it to get so......personal.
Lisa: Thanks for that link, it (and the following discussion) was very illuminating. Yes, for once in my life, I WANT to be 'normal' or at least stable. And I am learning a lot about boundries; about mine, about others and about what it feels like when people walk all over them.
lilwatchergirl: Yes, why is that I can "know" it isn't my fault and yet I still allow others to speak and treat me as if it is; I allow them to act as if knowing me or talking to me at all is their act of charity for the week - when did I get so low on myself, and how did I absorb this concept?
Elizabeth: I've only just started reading your blog (thanks, Sara!) but based on my first few impressions, I do think that you qualify for the alphabitch club. Our motto is "they don't call us bitches for nothing." I mean alla that in the nicest possible way, of course.
I'm actually fairly pleasant, in person. Mostly.
I do see what you mean about "I always believed life was a paradox, I just didn't expect it to get so......personal."
I've been struggling with that very lately here in my own head.
alphabitch: hmmmm, I have to check becuase I read your comment twice and both times read "I don't think that you qualify for the alphabitch club. Our motto is "they don't call us bitches for nothing.""
And I am thinking - "I come off too nice? I am projecting warm and fuzzy?" it is a new and unsettling experience - so many people have expected me to go bad, to be bad, or to end up a "bad girl" that the whole, "I'm too wholesome?" kind of made me think I should join an alpha course, even though I got thrown out of the last one for asking "Why does he always dress like Mr. Rodgers" about the guy in the videos (if you don't know what I am talking about......you still have those brain cells I lost).
Then I read it and it said "I DO think..."
So, I think I will just put myself on alphabitch probation until I know where I stand in term of verbs and verb negations.
Lol! Our little island would have much preferred a pride parade. Heck, we would've hopped on our tractors and joined in!
"I think I will just put myself on alphabitch probation until I know where I stand in term of verbs and verb negations."
See, this is why we don't have any meetings. Everybody makes all these decisions unilaterally, and nobody bothers to argue with them. You're obviously one of us. :)
"It isn’t just a question of suicide or thinking morbidly or the worst. You simply can’t experience pain like that and not NEED to know if that is what you are going to be facing more and more often."
I felt exactly this way before my first hip replacement. Wasn't suicidal, but pragmatically realized I couldn't live with that pain for the rest of my life without killing myself.
Mental Mosiac: well, it is decided then, once I get my spontanous relapse, I will use my time to take pride parades to small and isolated communities!
Alphabitch: Horaay, I'm in! I can't wait to tell my mother, she's always asking me if I have any noteworthy accomplishements she can tell the people at her church club.
Zephyr: So GOOD to see you - I was worried between school and your job (nothing like the "we are going to cut the weak every week" motivation meeting) you were going to be unavailable for a while. Yes, thank you for getting that and your experience, it just at some point, when you can think clearly again, you NEED to know how much, how long, how soon and what the options are.
Post a Comment